Should probably also be more specific and say 'inhabiting' rather than 'in'.
Present-day is not the problem. There's an ambiguity there because in can refer to at least three things if not more:
people in the location of the present-day New York fifty years ago (as intended)
people in present-day New York right now, physically and fifty years ago
people in present-day New York right now, but not fifty years ago
on closer inspection 'inhabiting' is not much better on these counts
You use the phrase when the name of a geographical area did not exist, or wasn't the same at the time you are referring to. So you wouldn't say "People in present-day Austria 50 years ago...", you just say "People in Austria 50 years ago." But you could very well say "People in present-day Austria 200 years ago..." since Austria then and now are different geographical areas.
You can say "Mozart was born in Salzburg in present-day Austria" and nobody would think it means he was born today.
Communication is about context.
The phrase 'present-day x' is also used to denote the setting in a script, novel, or magazine piece completely independent of this historical usage.
The context does not arrive until the end of the sentence and so I feel it is more like a punchline than a well written description.
The fragment “People in present day Austria” does not alone indicate the past, it requires “2700 years ago” to know for sure.
If you say “People in present day Austria drink beer”, it automatically implies people there today drink beer. If you say “People in present day Austria drank beer”, it implies they drank beer recently. “People in present day Austria drank beer 2700 years ago”, while eventually unambiguous that it means the past, still leads the reader on an unnecessary roller coaster of first implying the present and then clarifying it means the past.
"Present-day X" is a common stock phrase in English to talk about a place in the past while identifying it, for convenience, with today's political borders.
"Julius Caesar ruled over territory in present-day Italy, Tunisia, Spain, Turkey, (...etc)" is a perfectly normal sentence.
The order of the title makes it sound like present-day Austrians were around 2,700 years ago. The “present day” is applied to the wrong object.
I simply don’t agree: there was only one possible meaning, and it was obvious to me. I can’t prove it in any other way than citing my intuition as a native English speaker.
To my eyes your rewritten title has the same meaning and is no more or less clear.
Especially given that there are several trivial ways of reordering the sentence that makes it unambiguous.
The problem is not "present-day X". The problem is the position of "present-day X" within the sentence.
“Present day” is indeed a common phrase, but contrary to a few claims here, it is not normally used to place the subject of a sentence in the past. It is normally used opposite of that, to identify the time period as the present. Example: people in present day Babylon often drink beer. It would be weird to assume these people were drinking beer 3300 years ago and that I was talking about the past.
I have never seen anyone use the phrase like this. "present-day Babylon" is meaningless because there is no "Babylon" in the present day. "People drank beer thousands of years ago in present-day Iraq" would be valid, though.
Maybe look around? If you google “present day Babylon”, you will find many examples of exactly this usage. Present-day Babylon is referring to the region that used to be called Babylon, it has a perfectly clear meaning. I think this usage is in fact more common than referring to something current using the phrase “present day”. You don’t need to clarify present-day Iraq, because Iraq is the name of a current region, so it would be automatically assumed that you mean today’s borders, and far less confusing in your example if you left out “present day”.
Your example has the same primary problem as the article title, it’s mixing two time periods in a confusing way. The term “present day” is normally meant to signify that the sentence is discussing the present, not to invoke the past. That said, your example is slightly better than the title because it starts with “thousands of years ago”, and it’s clear the people drank beer thousands of years ago before you say “present day”.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Present_day
Edit: BTW, the term “present day” is not really the issue, we don’t need to debate the meaning of those two words. The problem is the larger fragment “people in present day Austria”, which implies by correct and common usage the same thing as “people presently in Austria”. The article title only becomes clear later on, when it clarifies 2700 years ago.
Source: am present-day Austrian.
I agree with the meaning of your example, but I don’t think your example illustrates the issue with the title. The title has “People in present day Austria” which implies these people are alive now, then goes on to say the same people ate something 2700 years ago.
Context does clarify the title, despite the confusing wording. Rewordings that would help: “Ancestors of modern day Austrians consumed blue cheese and beer 2700 years ago”, or “People who lived in what is now present-day Austria drank beer and ate blue cheese 2700 years ago.”
- "People in present day Austria" doesn't entirely capture the headline either because it's immediately followed by a verb in the past tense, thus specifying something that happened in the past;
- I don't think anyone ever refers to a place as 'present-day X' if they're talking about something that's happening now:
"Where are you going?"
"I'm going to present-day New York"
Using 'present-day' as an adjective to me necessarily implies a discussion of some past event. Can you imagine anyone talking about Austrians who are alive today as "people living in present-day Austria"?
Maybe this is why I'm a programmer and not an author...
Just as an example, Mozart was born in present-day Austria, but he was not born in Austria, since Salzburg were not part of Austria at the time.