I understand the business factors that require initial account creation to be frictionless, and so why proof of identity must be weak, but why can't account recovery offer an option where you prove your identity indisputably?
For example, some sort of physical storefront (possibly run by an independent company), where you go and say I am so-and-so and here's my ID and please take my picture and my fingerprints so that if I'm scamming I'll be easy to catch and here's twenty bucks for your trouble.
I'd rather do that then spend weeks or months locked out, uncertain, and talking to a wall.
Privacy advocates won't be happy, but Facebook, Google, etc. don't have the same motivations as privacy advocates.