If it's so great why are people not building it out of emacs :P
It's frustrating for me because I believe magit is the best git interface there is. Using it increases your understanding of git and decreases your chances of error. I'd really like the rest of my team to use it instead of the CLI. But when I think about it outside of emacs, it just doesn't work.
So yea, people are building it out of emacs!
Do you have any specific workflows that you prefer one over the other?