It was a melting pot of the British, the Irish, the Dutch, the French etc. In the old world all nations lived relatively isolated, save them whose profession involved travel, that was expensive and painstaking.
Make no mistake, the USA at the outset was meant to be an Anglo nation, not a melting pot.
Well the "many" failed in their opposition then. The default culture of the US is German, German is the largest self-reported ancestry group in the US.