> Where agile often went off the rails is when people implemented agile in a way that contradicts the four values
I can't remember a discussion about Agile in which the No true Scotsman fallacy wasn't mentioned at least once.
I can't remember a discussion about Agile in which the No true Scotsman fallacy wasn't mentioned at least once.
Please explain how the statement you quoted relates to the One True Scotsman fallacy. “It doesn’t work because you’re doing it wrong” is not an example of the fallacy.
(For example: “A: Light bulbs suck because they don’t light up when you smash them into your head. B: That’s not how lightbulbs work. A: No True Scotsman!” Yeah, no.)
"If your attempt at agile goes off the rails, you probably implemented it in a way that contradicts the four values".