Even if you assume the energy demands aren't an issue, and you could build these shallow pools, and find something to do with the captured carbon, you've probably just killed the Amazon by turning the Sahara into a series of ponds as the Sahara fertilizes the Amazon. You've probably also just caused insanely disruptive, and potentially catastrophic, changes to weather patterns by introducing obscene amounts of new moisture into the air over the Sahara which would almost certainly impact the entire planet's weather patterns.
Oh, you say you want to make a new tree that sequesters carbon better or is more ideal for reforestation? Like, oh, Maddie Hall is trying to do with Living cabron? Alright, great. But have you thought about the massive mycorrhizal networks that support forests, or the thousands of species per cubic meter of soil, or the fact that things that grow faster tend to fall over much easier and that the massive trees of the world are extremely slow growth, have you thought about how fast minerals might be stripped from fast growing trees, changes to weather, impact on the water table, did you just make a horribly invasive species, are you creating a tree that's a candy-filled playground for invasive insect species, is the species now outcompeting native ones that are necessary for any number of other species?
Etc., etc., so on and so forth.
In fact, humans aren't capable of predicting a chaotic system's outcome at all! It's the same for an economy - humans want to set policies for economic sustainability and growth, but every plan, every intervention and policy decision seems to have some negative externality not considered.
But I do know it would take less time to build a multi-planet civilization starting with the moon than trying to build a multi-planet civilization using geoengineering because the latter is by definition impossible.
And what's wrong with wanting a planet, if it is possible and economically feasible?
You can either make it last as long as possible, but know that it will eventually run out (or the island sinks), or you strike out on the ocean by building a raft.