in the wild I would be alert
I am when I hike alone. Not super alert - since there are few dangerous animals in my country - but alert still.Also, you are very alert when you walk in bad neighbourhoods.
I suspect that some other factor is responsible for the shrinkage. It could just be pure sexual selection. Maybe we find smaller more symmetrical heads to be more attractive and we sexually selected for them over tens of thousands of years. Also could be responsible for domesticated animal brain shrinkage, as we select for more attractive animals.
Could it be true that our brains got more complex even as they got smaller or did we legitimately lose some IQ points from the shrinkage?
A single narrative for all things is probably simpler than having to figure everything out every lifetime, like octopuses do.
Kind of hard to argue when we can today offload brain power used for memorization with a simple google search