Go defecate on a Black Lives Matter street sign and you can be sure to be hauled away and arrested. Chesa Boudin will even prosecute you.
Defecate in a public park in front of schoolchildren and people just look away and keep walking. SF has not gotten less principled, it just stopped being willing to defend public parks and city streets and instead chose to defend other things.
And the same people who insist we must allow millions of used needles in our parks are the ones claiming that "speech is violence". They are willing to fight to make sure that an offensive thing isn't said on twitter, but they're not willing to fight to make sure that children can play in the park without stepping on a used needle.
But in order to have civil society, you do need to defend it from antisocial people. There are always going to be antisocial people. And there are always going to be red lines that the community does not allow to be crossed. That red line could be wearing a MAGA hat in the SF community college, or it could be dying on the streets of the Tenderloin. The principles are enforced with the same strictness as 100 years ago, except that the principles themselves changed. SF tolerates one but not the other, and gets the streets and parks that it deserves.
I agree that it’s a messy, unstated process, and I understand that some may prioritize clean parks over human rights.
The fact is that dying on the streets of the tenderloin no longer violates social norms in the same way as, say, saying the N word in public. So again, you get the city you deserve -- one in which no one wears a MAGA hat, but homeless people screaming at strangers are a part of daily life.
At least have the integrity to admit that these are choices as to which norms you will enforce, and stop pretending that you just allow anyone to do whatever they want because of some fundamentalist adherence to free speech or free association.
In fact, I would argue that creating an environment in which this is permitted does a disservice to not just the local community, but to these people as well.
Yes, there is a line, but my opinion is that it’s closer to physical violence against another person’s body.
A possibly more interesting question: In what ways has the line been shifting over time, in what places, and why? What benefits have been reaped from increasing permissiveness, and why? What areas of the world are low-permissiveness, and what problems do they see as a result?
Is all of this coincident or causal to innovation, and why?
Why does this topic impassion people? Is clear thinking hindered by passion, and why?
This sounds like you're referencing something very specific, but I haven't been able to find anything credible about such an event. Got a link?