Couldn't the takeaway here be that life is allergic to Teflon?
Couldn't the takeaway here be that life is allergic to Teflon?
1. It's known to be a catalyst in the chemical reaction
2. They believe that the tiny pits in the corroded glass also speed up the reaction. This could explain why the material of the flask matters.
It would have been more convincing/thorough if they had also tried e.g. a steel and a silicon carbide reaction flask.
They might reasonably expect that the teflon, being far less reactive, did not appreciably influence the experiment.
Yes, the pure borosilicate flask had a much greater effect, but there was also much greater surface area for the solution to work on.
An interesting experiment might be to see if the reduction in PH levels scaled with the amount of borosilicate added to the solution. They may have done that in the paper, but that'd settle the question you posed.
Yes, it would take more experiments to further explore the role of the vessel material.
This is how science works in general; someone gets an idea and runs a limited experiment and gets results. Then other people, seeing the results and understanding the limitations, get their own ideas and test those.
What I’m trying to say is that you’re not wrong to say there is more to test here. But, it’s not a fatal flaw to this experiment. All experiments have limits to what they can prove.
Not the clearest way to phrase it, but I agree it most likely means the loose borosilicate bits worked too.