Obviously there's no need for them on Earth or anywhere nearby.
But it might become useful to scale nuclear explosions to an arbitrary extent if/when something large on a collision course with Earth is discovered.
Obviously there's no need for them on Earth or anywhere nearby.
But it might become useful to scale nuclear explosions to an arbitrary extent if/when something large on a collision course with Earth is discovered.
In particular, although these dispersion methods (as you pointed out) don't typically reduce the impact energy to zero, they offer a roughly 2 order-of-magnitude decrease in impact energy while requiring only month-scale warning.
In contrast, diversion techniques which can reduce the impact energy to 0 (e.g. by shifting the impactor to 'miss' our planet) can require decade-scale to accomplish their goal.
[0]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009457652...
It was from a reply to a question I'd asked recently here on HN that an eyewitness to the Chelyabinsk impactor reported on the heat of that event. Even as the impactor largely broke apart and vaporised 20--40km above the Earth, it shed a huge amount of heat over a large area. Not enough to be lethal, but enough to be felt.
A larger mass would deliver correspondingly more energy. And energy is conserved.
Correct, much of the atmosphere would become superheated, perhaps to plasma, and radiate the energy away non-directionally. So only half would radiate toward the surface -- not that that's a whole lot of help.
For a sufficiently large single impactor ... there's also an ejecta cloud, and for sufficient sizes (e.g., Chixulub+), that also results in atmospheric warming by a similar mechanism, though from secondary rather than primary fireballs. Several descriptions of the K-T mass extinction go into this mechanism in detail. Even at the antipodes, most exposed terrestrial life would have been subjected to at the very least uncomfortable, and probably lethal, heat.
I've had the experience of feeling radiated heat from a bushfire (and a relatively small one at that), and even at 100s of meters distance, it could be distinctly felt, with the sense that this wasn't just a nearby small heat source (a radiator or firepit), but a large conflagration. The prospect of a wall of flame sweeping down a hillside, or of a sky on fire, is slightly more real to me since that.
Area of impact for original rock: 78.5 km2 Area of impact for a 1000-km dust cloud: 785,398 km2
Asteroids that struck 65 million years ago had 3×10 ^23 joules In case of dusk cloud, that's 382,000 Megajoules per square meter impacted
A column of air with a cross-sectional area of 1 square centimetre (cm2 has a mass of about 1.03 kilogram A square meter of air column weighs ~10 tons Heat capacity of air is 1.0035 joules per gram per degree centigrade So it's 10 MJ to heat up 1 m^2 of atmosphere by 1 degree
So if all the energy was absorbed, converted to heat, and evenly distributed vertically (unrealistically), it the atmosphere would heat to 38,000 degrees. If this is in the right ballpark, then radiation will dominate this equation, which I can't estimate. Upper atmosphere will be heated to a glow, and will radiate away most of this energy. Whatever happens, not a happy scenario.
For a dust cloud 5,000 km in diameter, situation is quite different: 3,821 megajoules per square meter, that's 382 degrees rise per square meter. For comparison, the Sun provides 115 Mj/m2 per day.
I would anticipate that in case of 5000 KM dust cloud there wouldn't be a major loss of life - the atmosphere doesn't conduct heat very well, so most of it would be stuck in upper atmosphere and radiated away. I think a realistic 'space dust cloud' would disperse very quickly to greater than earth radius, but it's not going to be uniform dust.
The initial pulverisation would presumably result in a distribution of velocities amongst particles. Some of those would achieve escape velocity and leave the cloud. Some would not.
Time to re-coalesce would depend on the total cloud mass and maximum extant itself. In total, it would be relatively quickly.
The resulting re-agglomerated impactor would then resemble a rubble-pile or the World's Largest Dust Bunny. It would be significantly disrupted by both tidal forces and interactions with the atmosphere, though of course, how greatly it is disrupted by atmospheric friction would again be a function of mass.
But the point remains: under the influence of the cloud's own gravity a cloud of merely separated particles will re-coalesce. You can look up in the night sky much of the time to see an example of this yourself, the Earth's moon.
And again, depending on the mechanism, a fair fraction of particles, quite possibly / probably the majority, will approach the original centroid of the mass.
In practice, pulverising planets and/or planetoids is likely a challenging proposition. Early experimentation on animal models tends to support this hypothesis:
Though the point remains that what you've got to do is avoid impacting the asteroid entirely, whether it's a single solid core or a dispersed dust-cloud. Or more precisely, the total delivered energy has to be considered and kept to a survivable maximum.
That said, I'm now wondering what it would look like to suddenly have a sub-lethal dust-cloud impact Earth. I imagine there'd be an initial few stray shooting stars, then a rapidly-growing glow as the dust struck the atmosphere. Hrm...
I am in favor of numbers in a discussion like this, even if wrong, (and I am not a physicist) they're more interesting than without.
- The asteroids considered a threat to the Earth start at about 460 feet in diameter. This is about an order of magnitude less (in diameter, not mass) than the impact that got the dinosaurs but would still probably be a lot worse than anything in recorded history, if it hit land or sea. It's said to be about a 10,000 year level.
- Density is uncertain, but I found a figure of 2.7 g / cm^3 as a mid range.
- This equates to 3.9 million metric tons or more being probably what we would want to do something about.
- Freeman Dyson wrote a paper in 1968 or so, about nuclear pulse rocket design, that described a hypothetical spacecraft that would mass forty million metric tons.
- It would, however, accelerate very slowly; at 0.00003 g (supposedly).
- But that's really not so slow.
- Ignoring orbital mechanics, because I just can't right now, if something is headed for Earth, it should be enough to move it by one radius in some direction...right?
- Earth is something like 7926 miles in diameter, and 6.4 megameters is ~half that.
- d = 1/2at^2, 1/2a = 0.000147 m/s^2, so divide the radius by 0.000147, take the square root, and I get ~209,000 seconds.
- That is...2.4 days!
- However, it presumes a one megaton bomb going off every 100 seconds, for a total of around 2,100.
- That sounds like a lot. On the other hand, it's less than 3% of the nuclear bombs the US has produced since 1945.
- However they would have to be custom designed, is my impression, as "nuclear shaped charges" and not just recycled warheads.
- The asteroid might have to be reinforced on the size that was being pushed. The spacecraft design included a 1mm thick sheet of copper to absorb thermal energy.
- However, if the asteroid was four and not forty million tonnes, then less time and fewer explosions would be needed, I would assume. Would it be ten times less? I'm leaving that as an exercise for the reader.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propuls...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_weapons_of_the_United_...
Moving an asteroid is a lot more plausible than you'd think, but it would require "normal" sized bombs, not super gigantic ones.