Allies lobby Biden to prevent shift to ‘no first use’ of nuclear arms
ft.com
ft.com
Couldn't the "set of circumstances" include retaliating after an attack on an ally by a nuclear-armed nation (or alliance)?
Naively we might want a global "no escalation" treaty/convention/commitment, which would compel countries to not use nuclear weapons to respond to conventional attacks, but that would make it very hard for the US to protect Taiwan against invasion by China, or SK from invasion by NK, or Estonia from Russia, or Israel from Iran.
There are perhaps other strategic goals of the US nuclear umbrella, but a commitment to only using nukes against nuclear-armed adversaries would at least give countries some incentive to remain non-nuclear.