There are many (maybe all) examples from nature in which resources will get consumed until they are gone. "Logic" has nothing to do with it. That doesn't mean we should hunt species to extinction, but its definitely a natural thing to do.
I guess the GP post is simply a direct quote from "Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home" (where IIRC Spock says something along those lines while he and Kirk visit a 20th century museum).
Whales, their extinction and communicating with them was central to the plot of that film.
EDIT: Ok, I looked it up. This exact quote is in the movie, verbatim, in the scene I mentioned. At around 00:47:39
As opposed to two decades ago (right column): https://www.webdesignmuseum.org/gallery/icq-2001
That we are so terrible at modesty of consumption in groups is the real tragedy.