Unfortunately 630 other people upvoted it.
I do upvote this "Debunk" article http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2906538
Important conclusion:
In news ranking I would clearly prefer to rely on subset of Hacker News readers. Not on the full set.
I actually would prefer not to see articles that are upvoted by the same people who upvoted junk science article.
The moment I start loving HN, I start seeing such Aspergeristic tendencies. So downvote me to hell, but I am stuck between people loving kittens & user-generated 'rage' comics, and between people cannot appreciate broad philosophical ideas.
PS: This comment does not have much to do with what the parent said, but a broader problem with HN. And somehow I think this too (like the orignal comment) will be misinterpreted and downvoted to oblivion.
I don't think that's worthy of downvoting. Still, I think you might get more satisfaction from HN if you framed your arguments more clearly instead of blaming the readers for what you see as their Aspergistic tendencies.
Also to talk about 'Aspergistic tendencies', it's a negative term and I used it because I was irritated. But I would like any of you to please answer this. How should I have phrased the first line any other way, and not appear arrogant. 'We all' is a construction of language thing, to take all off you in the fold. And I think it was pretty obvious 'we all' did not mean literally all. And anyone engaging in a bit of second-order thought could have deciphered that. One can say that the problem is partially because many HN readers are not native English speakers, but I would say neither am I, and it's more of an attitude thing. Programming is almost completely literal, most life is not.
How should I have phrased the first line any other way, and not appear arrogant.
The original: "A bigger point here is how we all mistook the results."Suggested revision: "It's odd that an article that now appears mistaken originally received over 600 upvotes. I wonder how many people would downvote it, given the chance."