When it was shut down and seized and its founders prosecuted, it was a win for the DoJ PR department and for dangerous sex traffickers, and a loss for the rest of the world.
I’m morally against all of this myself in principle, but you can’t just endorse prohibition without considering the consequences: even if all this is bad you can’t just say “this is bad!!” as an excuse for making it significantly worse as you lie to the public and slander the operators.
From Stamping Out Online Sex Trafficking May Have Pushed It Underground (Dec 2019)
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/17/technology/fosta-sex-traf...
I'm not sure why Craiglist personals weren't okay, but the same exact thing on Tinder or Bumble is.
Not wishing to go to jail, they chose to remove anything that could possibly be used against them.
Craigslist had already been targeted multiple times by law enforcement, and had revised the structure and policies of their personals sections multiple times to try to stop that. SESTA/FOSTA was when they gave up trying to find a way to make it work, but it wasn't just the Backpage example.
Its the same about wondering why one person gets culturally “cancelled” and another doesn't for the same action: The people beside them have a large enough rainy day fund and don't mind the risk. It says nothing about what the culture actually believes either way, only the risk tolerance of the wealthy backers. Huh, reminds me of the princeton study that said the same thing about progressive laws that get passed, where the culture has no effect on anything except that sometimes it coincidentally matches what wealthy special interests were already doing, with the caveat that its more of a direct democracy for the wealthy special interests but an additional level of representative democracy for everyone else.
https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20210728/13245147264/enoug...
The short version: it is pretty obvious that it did what the people pushing it wanted it to do, but it did not do what they said it would do. They continue to lie about it in multiple ways.
The same actors are currently targeting payment processors in their continued attempts to conflate and ban prostitution, trafficking, pornography, nudity and frequently sex education wherever they can.
https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20211008/17285147720/prudi...