The employer makes an offer; the candidate accepts, declines, or counters. The employer can certainly offer to underpay but if the candidate rejects it, they won’t succeed at it.
Is it really a good idea to negotiate salary with someone whose starting offer is well below market rate? I mean, even if you feel you can get a change of heart out of them, is that really the character you want in someone who can have a considerable impact on your well being and even life?