This may be wrong, but a friend in logistics once told me that some companies insure large shipments to a partial amount.
So if you budget to lose X% of shipments a year that's inline with the savings of Y% payments.
So if you budget to lose X% of shipments a year that's inline with the savings of Y% payments.
The possible cases I can see are: the insurance prices are reasonably fair (roughly equal to risk percent times insured value, plus some profit buffer), or they're significantly higher or lower than that "fair" amount. Given that, I have trouble seeing a case where the rational action is insuring part of the value. If the cost is significantly higher than the risk-adjusted value, then it wouldn't make sense to insure at all, and if it's roughly equal or significantly lower then it would make sense to insure as much as possible.