> This is a logic fallacy, but I don't know the name of it. "We all agree that all students can't have a penthouse. So why do you care if we stuff them in windowless rooms?"
False dichotomy
False dichotomy
> Exaggerating (sometimes grossly exaggerating) an opponent's argument, then attacking this exaggerated version.
The claim in this case being, "residents should have reasonable access to sunlight in their rooms." And the exaggeration being penthouses.