I guess also, are the 4 unused cores always the same?
As far as which cores are demoted… I definitely don’t know enough to speculate. If favoring the same set would affect longevity of the device, they’d rotate. If not it’s simpler not to do that. I have no idea which is more likely.
“I suspect that Apple has done this to further improve energy efficiency and ensure good responsiveness to new CPU-intensive tasks.”
Probably the "high power" mode available on an M1 Max in a 16" chassis is doing just that. And maybe Apple will decide to treat some kind of new iMac Pro as more of a pro machine, and make it chunky enough to dissipate that sort of heat without needing much fan noise...
Obviously a 'Pro' version of the iMac is coming eventually with a larger screen but I don't think many people expected that yet. Maybe February or so next year...
Also, even a huge company like Apple would want to stagger releases so design teams can have some constant workload. Releasing laptops and a new Mini and a new iMac would put quite some work on the team and then it would be idle for a time. They are probably done with the Mini and working on a Mac Pro right now.