It doesn't work that way. The gnome maintainers have certain ideals that IMO are out of sync with most users and they are completely hostile to most PRs. I've seen tons of PRs denied with bizzare rationales and crucial functionality ripped out of gnome in their efforts to 'streamline'. This leads to everyone having a laundry list of extensions that break or stop being maintained and it just isn't ideal or user-friendly. Want to do something as simple as drag a file to your desktop? Oh you need a gnome extension for that etc etc. We need more DE choices.
At this point I just want someone to build a desktop environment that makes people not have to think about the word "desktop environment", and nobody seems to actually give a crap about that goal. Except for Google, which is why the only Linux on the desktop product that's successful is Chrome OS.
They are perfectly happy. The only problem that arises from time to time are some weird-ass Windows applications that refuse to run with even Wine.
Gnome is a smooth desktop that's easy to grasp and gets out of your way and definitively not aimed at Linux admins.
For those there's tmux.
And then everyone started clapping
Oh, sorry. You got a point?
My point is that I can make stuff up too! If you need evidence that linux is just not ready for non-technical user prime time just take a look at the ltt video from yesterday:
Because that kind of shit also happens on Windows. With administrative access, you can always kill your machine.
What Linux lacks and what Windows has more then enough is informal support services. You know, that person in the family that just knows their way around computers, that does computer stuff.
(Almost) every elderly person above a certain age is lost when it comes to computers. Most people alive cannot be trusted to install an application - not on Windows, not on Linux and not even on OS X (well, maybe on OS X nowadays, because you cannot install unsigned software these days) because all that software might be compromised. Every time you let a software on to your system, you can potentially brick it. And then you need a solid understanding of what's going on.
For most people, computers are black boxes whose internal state is a mystery that is far too complex to be explored. They have no interest in exploring these mysteries. They have work to do; forms to fill, letters to write. And these people need the aforementioned informal support they can turn to whenever they need to diverge from the well-trodden paths. It doesn't depend on the operating system, but on the surrounding support system.
That's why I don't consider that video evidence that Linux isn't ready for prime time, just as I wouldn't consider a video of someone bricking their Windows as evidence that Windows isn't ready for prime time.
These people just need someone they can ask for help. For my family - that me.
Really? because gnome is one of the most hostile communities to contributors there is. So not you can not just "contribute" to it.
gnome devs are very very very opinionated, they are worse than Apple. it is gnome devs way, or it is wrong...
yea no thanks
But there are a reason by DE's like this new one, unity before it, and others that are either off shoots of gnome, or come from developers that are completely frustrated with the obtuse nature of the gnome team
as was highlighted above, System76 ships a forked version of gnome with popos because none of their changes, their contributions, were not accepted by gnome.
gnome is very opinionated about how users should use their desktops, how other software devs should write a application for gnome, and are unwilling to change in their positions even if the face wide scale community, user, or developer desire for the change.
From my point of view gnome devs do not build gnome for the gnome community gnome devs build gnome for themselves, and if others use it ok, but they do not really care if they do
Well, yes. They are the devs. It's their project and so they get to decide what goes in. That not different with any other project.
> obtuse nature of the gnome team
That has been often repeated, but has not been my experience. Yes, the Gnome developers, such as any good team - has a clear vision of what their product should be and a process they are following. Most of the time, there are excellent reasons for their decisions. Sometimes technical, sometimes pragmatic. In some cases it's just aesthetics. But that's not different from any other free/open source projects. There are dozens of projects that are forked and forked again because of aesthetic, technical, social or idealistic differences.
> as was highlighted above, System76 ships a forked version of gnome with popos because none of their changes, their contributions, were not accepted by gnome.
Well, that's .. good, I guess? I mean, that System76 have forked version of Gnome that confirms more to their vision of a desktop.
That's the beauty of free/open software; no one is beholden to a single company calling the shots.
> From my point of view gnome devs do not build gnome for the gnome community gnome devs build gnome for themselves, and if others use it ok, but they do not really care if they do
I would argue that the Gnome developers very much are a part of the Gnome community. Yes, they build it for themselves, or for the companies paying them to build it.
The primary commercial contributors to Gnome - companies like Endless, Redhat, Ubuntu, SuSE - are not single-mindedly interested in Gnome's market share. They have larger offerings, of which Gnome is only a part. They have nothing to gain from - say - Gentoo switching to Gnome (except maybe additional developers, but that's not a given). Why should
To be clear here the comment I replied to, that you then replied to was about "why do we need another DE, just contribute to gnome"
I explained why, your attempt at "refuting" my position is "well they do not need to accept your contributions because it is their project"
This is amazing circular logic...
You are correct they are free to run their project however they want, and we are free to fork or create other DE's that meet our needs.. but again this was a comment about linux getting yet another DE, and the growing compliant that linux has too many DE's
Linux has too many DE's because projects like gnome have a narrow focus that only care about their own goals and give 2 shits less if you do not agree with them. That is fine... but then people need to stop saying "dont fork, contribute"
> detail why
which you dind't. You just answered with a general attack on the Gnome devs saying - I paraphrase - that they are arseholes that don't to your bidding.
I then tried to get more detail and asked explicitly for your experiences with contributing to Gnome, because I didn't have bad experiences at all. So far, you didn't tell me if and what you tried to contribute or what exactly your experiences were.
> This is amazing circular logic...
If anything, it amazing lack at deflection. Common, spit it out. Where did the bad Gnome devs touch you?
> Linux has too many DE's because projects like gnome have a narrow focus that only care about their own goals and give 2 shits less if you do not agree with them. That is fine... but then people need to stop saying "dont fork, contribute"
Nowhere in this thread was this expressed. Instead it was "Why cannot you contribute" to which you just answer with a stale old general and lame excuse ("They have a narrow focus and only care about their own goals" - no really, to they? The meanies!) that can be applied to every open source project out there.
I'm sick and tired of people dumping on the Gnome devs. They are doing a great job and a promising idea of a desktop that goes beyond the desktop of the 80ies and 90ies. Almost all of the complaints come from people that have neither the interest nor the ability to truly contribute and find it easier to simply complain and bitch about. Sad!
If you truly want to contribute and better Gnome - convince them!
Start by fixing papercuts and show them that you are able. Get involved at the design stage and bring in your brilliant ideas. Take over responsibility in the team and make sure that your good decision making powers are acknowledged in the team.
Don't just jump in from the side with your one-trick-pony issue, shouting in their faces and then complain an moan if they don't immediately obey. That's lame.
Which seems for both gnome, and now windows even means "Lets look at what Apple is doing and copy them"
I hate Mac OS, I do not want to use a Mac, if I did I would buy a Mac. The fact that gnome wants to mirror their style and function to that of Apple is the problem I (and MANY MANY MANY others) have and they do not see to have any desire to change.
>Nowhere in this thread was this expressed.
It has been expressed mutiple points in this thread, and is the over arching implication in "why dont you just contribute to make gnome better"
The reason is because "better" is subjective and subjectively people like the popos devs that are making their own DE's and others that have walked away from gnome feel gnome is worse, not better, and the people that control gnome have no interest in making it "better" for users like me.
That's an accusation that gets thrown around from time to time. In what aspect do you think that Gnome is copying Apple/Mac?
> It has been expressed mutiple points in this thread, and is the over arching implication in "why dont you just contribute to make gnome better"
I'm only talking about the thread back to the root of the discussion that we're (hopefully) having. It's possible that this was expressed somewhere else in this HN discussion but not by me and not by the OP (of the thread).
> the people that control gnome have no interest in making it "better" for users like me.
Well, yes. They don't. In my opinion, that has multiple reasons:
1) There are no 'users like me'.
Let me explain. There's a bunch of very vocal (former/one-time/ongoing) Gnome users that are unhappy with various "things" that Gnome is doing. But these "things" are never the same and there is no agreement on how it ought to be done, just that Gnome is doing it "wrong". So there's no 'making it "better" for users like me". Any change could be loved by one part of that unhappy group, disliked by another, loathed by a third and seen as beside-the-point for the remainder. There are no "users like me".
2) No pitching in.
When I hear people complaining about Gnome, about the devs and how awful they are and how mean, I seldom (never?) get any links to examples of bad interactions. It at all, I get pointers to the gitlab.gnome.org bug tracker where there's a bunch of complaints from the peanut gallery about how bad the Gnome devs are. Most of the complains come from users that have did not contribute to Gnome whatsoever. Except the complaints and rants and insults. I do have an idea why the Gnome devs would rather ignore the input of such users.
And frankly, I found a few cases where they were not rational, but more often then not, sticking to what they thought out did absolutely make sense. Like, in case of a DE, the whole UX is the product - so analogously it would be like accepting random contributions regarding your business logic in a CRUD app. These need planning.
Also, I think their vision is actually really cool, I much prefer vanilla gnome to whatever mess windows created, and especially with a good touchpad, gnome’s gestures are fantastic. So at least I am very thankful for their great work!
I am glad you think gnome vision is cool and good. I do not not. vanilla gnome3 was really terrible IMO and basically unusable. I moved away from gnome when ti came out, I have not messed with gnome40 much but what I have seen they are continuing down the same path and are much to Mac OS like for me.
I prefer DE's like MATE, XFCE, Budgie or these days even move to tilling window managers..