People can "end up" unintentionally evasive(aka confusing) and having a structure and strategy for keeping them on track is key.
People can "end up" unintentionally evasive(aka confusing) and having a structure and strategy for keeping them on track is key.
I mean, yes if you take it very literally - but why limit yourself? Here's an example of using the "one question one fact" technique for a non-hostile "interrogation" that's almost verbatim from last week:
Colleague (super irate): everyone who works here is a fucking incompetent idiot! We need to fire half our team!
Me: Was there a production problem last night?
Colleague: Yes
Me: did we roll out some bad logic?
Colleague: Yes
Me: Was the logic obviously bad?
Colleague: Yes!!!!
Me: was there a code review that missed it?
Colleague: Yeah
Me: who reviewed it?
Colleague: Bob.
Me: wasn't Bob the reviewer the last time something obvious broke?
Colleague: Yeah...
Me: we should help Bob become a stronger reviewer.
Colleague: Agreed!
Did I interrogate my colleague? Sort of. Was it hostile? Not at all. Did the one fact one question form help him get from "we should fire half the team" to "we need to help Bob"? Yup. Was that a vital recognition to make things better? Yup. Could we have gotten there so quickly if I didn't intentionally structure the conversation? Probably not.
You’re addressing the wrong problem. They are frustrated at the situation, not suggesting a course of action. Acknowledge their feelings (because you probably have the same frustration). Then you can work the conversation around on how to fix the problem. Maybe they see something you don’t. But you’ll never know that with your example.
I get the "make sure they are OK" angle - totally the go-to if someone is seriously distraught or vulnerable.
This was a manager annoyed from perceiving themselves drowning in a sea of incompetence. Helping him go from that to "this is something I can help my team with" was empowering to him as is obvious in the actual example.
You really can't imagine a situation where simply helping someone navigate their own understanding is helpful?
While I am an advocate for mental health now, I’ve been doing everything I talked about for the last decade. Maybe two if you include what I picked up from my parents doing marriage counseling.
> You really can't imagine a situation where simply helping someone navigate their own understanding is helpful?
Here’s my way to address that:
“Yeah. That last deployment was rough. I’m sick and tired of this happening too. What we are doing isn’t effective. I’ve been thinking about this and I have a few ideas. When would be a good time to discuss? I’m free now or we could talk after lunch.”
Now I can have a conversation with someone willing to look at solutions instead of venting.
The point is to take the word soup and turn it into an action. As a manager or someone investigating a problem, your goal is to resolve the issue. Reinforcing the state of emotional whatever is a barrier to that goal.
People tend to segment their thinking based on their role. Validation of “everyone is stupid, except me” doesn’t put you on a good path.
Depending on your relationship with the person, you can defuse things any number of ways. The goal is to switch them from thinking emotionally to thinking logically. Humor works well.
I’ve said something like this in the past: “Hold up, let’s see if we can fix this before we start executing volunteers. The paperwork just isn’t worth it.”
It's great when someone wants it, but do it often enough or by default and people will start cutting you out of the loop. Because it's genuinely exhausting.
I've been on both sides of this, especially when I did coaching training and then thought I could use it for everyone.
This is a great point and totally agree. It's a little frustrating to have to spell out the entire context of the relationship in this case but people are for some reason eager to assume a context that puts the conversation in the worst possible light rather than seeing "oh yeah ok sometimes there's room for that kind of thing" and obviously you wield the tool with judgement.
One thing I really do appreciate is that some workplaces seem more geared for coaching and feedback than others. I haven't worked at Amazon for example but I understand that one of the reasons it's considered a hard place to work is that it's "not OK" to not want to improve and grow, so you give implicit consent to be coached by working there (obviously there's still room for empathy and handing it well) whereas other organizations (Google) seem to prioritize in-the-moment happiness so there's potential to be missing out on vital feedback for years - I actually asked about this a lot in my interviews there.
Recent example was "we need that person to fill this info manually, because she is communicating with other department". After deep diving with him by similar method, I discovered that opposite is true.