It does sound like you expected more performance out of the 8gb model than was reasonable.
I don’t think it’s a wholly unfair assessment. You can get away with more when the memory management stack is smart and fast, but in the end if you need 9gb of ram and only have 8gb you’re going to know it. Most people just don’t (at one time).
So I got it knowing as soon as the 16GB dropped in stores I'd replace it