Then, Darcs has never been slow for me, I've been using it for about 15 years, I can remember of one minor performance issue. It doesn't scale well to very large projects, but there are extremely few of them. Since concrete arguments are important when discussing with others, the main event which started Darcs' decline was its inability to handle conflicts in GHC (the Haskell compiler), which was at the time the open source project with the largest history (as measured in number of patches).
As for Pijul, I'm curious where you got your information from. I know Pijul's authors well, at least enough to know that they are well aware of the algorithms used in Git. Pijul does solve a number of problems:
- I know at least one very large-scale project where collaborators are well aware that 3-way merge can mess with their code in really bad ways, and complain about wasting tons of time with that. Unfortunately, I can't embarrass the project's authors by sharing their name, but I can say that it is a widely used piece of software with a really long history.
- Knowing that the code you review is the code you merge is the only thing you should care about if you care about your code at all. This is not what 3-way merge gives you, as the Pijul manual clearly explains (see "lack of associativity").
- Patch commutation is what Git tries to do all the time (rebase, merge, rerere…), except with bad hacks which fail in the more complex situations, which is where we need them the most.