The in app payment system was exclusive (and advertising other payments forbidden) because IAP was how apple extracted their royalties for platform use by app developers.
This only changed the ability to freely link to external payment options. It does not require Apple to allow in-app payments, it does not forbid Apple from requiring a royalty/commission on those external payments.
So now the firewall is gone, and there could be really ugly fights where developers are told to prove they are in compliance with whatever commission scheme is coming. This could even result in Apple now extracting additional revenue from developers.
If Apple has higher costs getting their commission because of payments outside of the App Store, I would 100% expect they will pass that cost on to developers.
To give Google as an example, they now charge an 11% commission on payments made using third party processors in South Korea.
At the moment I can be sure that I can cancel a subscription without, for example, being required to call a US telephone number, as is the norm for subscription sites not using Apple.
It's a huge win for developers who want to fuck over consumers. Consumers? Not so much.
For me, the consumer choice is made when choosing whether I want that walled garden experience with iOS or a more flexible experience with Android.
That 30% cut apple takes means you are paying 43% more for apps than you would have if apple didn't take their cut. I'd rather deal with a shitty subscription cancellation experience than pay 43% more money for something.
edit: also I reject the idea that using third party payment processors will result in a bad experience. 99% of apps will use paypal for payment processing and managing subscriptions on paypal is super easy.
There is an ongoing competition for the last 20 years, where we are today is the result of that competition.
Developers ran away from Symbian, webOS, Windows Mobile, Windows Phone and RIM to Android and iOS.
Developers want to develop for platforms with great APIs, hardware and great distribution.
Consumers want to stick on platforms with active developers.
RIM, Nokia, Palm and others tried, burned billions, but the market (via consumers and developers) has spoken.
It’s no easy feat for new entrants (Google & Apple) to dethrone existing players sitting there for decades.
But they’ve done it and turned others into history and a business lesson about innovation and how changing the status quo can disrupt existing markets.
Ease of cancellation? Right now, no big app (except games) uses IAP anyway, because they don't want to give 30% profits to Apple. So you already need to go to Netflix.com, Disney.com, Kindle.com to cancel subscriptions. Zero difference.
I just don't see what value Apple is adding here. Sure, friction means that you probably won't give your CC details to a 6$/year weather app subscription, but you be willing to buy it with IAP. But devs will still be able to provide IAPs, you know? And if they decide not to, you can just avoid those apps. What difference will it make in the average user's day?