> How effective do you think that is?
In the short term, very. In the long term, as in once the kids are off to college and so on, who knows. But, overall I think much more effective than the households/kids with unrestricted access.
> your kid and effectively ostracizing them.
This is an interesting one. If the kids are educated as to why a certain action is being taken, as opposed to just No then kids can accept the policy and be fine with it. Messaging such as Signal or iMessage is allowed, but I just don't understand as to why kids have to share million selfies each day. So anything out of the Zuck-factory is a complete no-no.
Bottom line, I'd rather ostracize kids in the short term than cause longer term psychological harm.
> If ten million parents have a social media addicted child, you have a policy problem.
I never said don't do policy, but that is not a substitute for better parenting.
Let me ask this, will the same parent who allow their kids unfettered access to social media allow their kids similar access to porn websites? I'm pretty sure they won't. Which is why it's not either/or, it's both. This is why I said that the narrative is incomplete.