https://asia.nikkei.com/Spotlight/Society/China-s-largest-gh...
Wade Shepard, author of Ghost Cities of China:
> Today, China’s so-called ghost cities that were so prevalently showcased in 2013 and 2014 (...) have filled up to the point of being functioning, normal cities
I would be really, really skeptical of post-2012 reporting on China. I understand why people are increasingly anti-China (the Uyghur stuff is disgusting) but you really don't get close to a neutral perspective from most of the Western media.
Or even closer to Beijing in Tianjin's new financial district. Actually, the tallest building in China is an incomplete sky scraper in Tianjin (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldin_Finance_117), which hasn't had any work done on it since 2015 or so (similar to North Korea's Ryugyong Hotel).
> but you really don't get close to a neutral perspective from most of the Western media.
If anything considering my 9 years living in Beijing, western media holds off on a lot of crazy things that happen in China. No one would actually believe the reality, they would think it was all made up (e.g. the incomplete sky scraper in Tianjin).
> You can go visit Kangbashi (Ordos's new distrcit) today (well, when China opens again) if you want to see a ghost city. Kangbashi will fill up as soon as coal becomes popular in China again, which is probably never.
If you read the article I posted, Kangbashi is specifically the district under discussion - it is no longer empty, actively building new apartments due to demand.
Coal didn't become popular again, but they moved the top schools of the province into the area.
Every time I've visited Tianjin, I've seen a derelict half built sky scraper. The first time I visited was in 1999. What is up with that city?
> There are tons of unfinished projects scattered throughout the West.
In the USA? There are none, not sky scrapers. Maybe that half built Huawei facility in Wisconsin?
> I actually was just next to a massive one (not in the US but in Europe)
Great! Eastern or Western Europe?
> If you read the article I posted, Kangbashi is specifically the district under discussion - it is no longer empty, actively building new apartments due to demand.
Kangbashi was originally specced for a few million people. It has...maybe a hundred thousand now? The streets are still pretty empty compared to the rest of Urban Ordos.
> Coal didn't become popular again, but they moved the top schools of the province into the area.
They moved one top school to the area. Will it be enough? Can you make a city by relocating a few middle school and university campuses? That only gives you so much growth.
There's pros and cons to either system, but so far, the demand has largely arrived. The ghost cities of 2010 are now bustling metropolises. The ghost cities of 2020... Are on track to become bustling metropolises.
China has added ~500 million people to its cities over the past 50 years. 'Build in anticipation of demand' seems like a sensible approach to this sort of thing.
Speculators blocking new building is also a problem.
Everyone needs housing, but when owning a house means it has a speculative resale value, you have to pay that premium in order to buy one.
This has a few consequences:
1. Downpayments and mortgages grow, because you aren't just buying shelter, you are buying a financial instrument with a significant resale value.
2. Your financial well-being is now deeply entwined in the fate of the housing and mortgage market. Higher interest rates become horrible for you, as they depress housing prices, and put your home underwater. New construction is horrible to you, as it reduces the value of the speculative portion of your purchase. Likewise for the existence of affordable forms of housing, and renter-friendly legislature.
Speculation from the perspective of a developer is part of running a business. They shoulder a fair amount of financial risk when they choose to develop, and obviously want to hedge it. Speculation as a 'every homeowner in the country is also a speculator, whether they want to be one or not' leads to some questionable outcomes.
2. yes, people should be expected to pay the time discounted expected future value of the thing in order to own the thing. speculation is what prevents people from buying shitty houses for dirt cheap in areas that are ideal for apartment development and then refusing to move - that is a good thing.
2 -> Yes agreed, it is bad how it distorts the incentives and when the people on one side of the transaction (usually the homeowners) have all or most of the political power, that becomes a large problem.
The reality is that we have to have a mechanism to encourage people to sell their homes and move when more valuable uses become available (like moving in 30 people into an apartment building where there were previously
Speculation, in the United States, is that mechanism. There are probably alternatives (as a sketch: devolving eminent domain authority to local govt & non-profits -> obtain financing for compensating owners -> eminent domain-ify vacant lots/unused parking lots -> build housing -> sell housing -> pay back creditors; this would probably do a ton), but currently speculation & financialization is the best engine for resource allocation in the US.
That really isn't true. Kangbashi (a district of Ordos in Inner Mongolia) is still pretty empty for the amount of infrastructure they've built. They "lowered" their population target and claimed success, and are trying to get people to move there by putting in a good school, but you can still go there to see empty boulevards.
Likewise, China's tallest building is an incomplete skyscraper in Tianjin that hasn't had any work done on it since 2015. Tianjin also overbuilt on a new financial district that no one is really interested in.
Many of these overbuilt buildings are never going to be lived in before they are torn down. They just aren't in very convenient locations (e.g. not enough jobs to sustain those areas and no one wants to commute in traffic to where their are jobs).
I wonder how will WFH affect it though. Even with cultural resistance, WFH long-term seems inevitable on so many levels.