Hacker News Reader

Comment by hristov | Hacker News Reader

As somebody already mentioned below, the case in question is based on a design patent. A design patent only protects the ornamental design of something not how something works.

A tablet shown in a movie is a perfectly fine and perfectly usable example of a publication of an ornamental design.

View on HN

It appears to have a control panel with buttons along the bottom of the screen tilted at an angle. Does the iPad? No-one touches its screen that I noticed, but I'm not sufficiently motivated to sit through 2001 to find out for sure.

Samsung's theft of Apple's very specific decorative designs (witness their remote that looked EXACTLY like an iPhone 4) is so egregious that if it were, say, a nameless Chinese entrepreneur selling knockoff purses in Chinatown no-one would be especially surprised if their stock were seized and a few people imprisoned over it. This isn't, say, Ferrari suing Maserati for creating a coupe with four wheels, it's Ferrari suing Hyundai for creating a coupe that looks EXACTLY like the current model Ferrari. No offense to Hyundai -- they pay actual designers to design their ugly-ass cars.

You definition of exactly just has to be funny.

The 'exactly' part is especially funny, given that the tablets have a different screen size and aspect ratio, as was obvious when people looked at properly scaled photos side by side.

So, I take it you haven't seen this:

http://electroniclover.info/samsung-touch-control-rmc30d-uni...

I'm well aware that Samsung's tablets have different aspect ratios to Apple's. I made no claim _they_ were EXACTLY anything.

  > it's Ferrari suing Hyundai for creating a coupe
  > that looks EXACTLY like the current model Ferrari.

s/Ferrari/Apple/g; s/Hyundai/Samsung/g; s/coupe/pad/g

It was your analogy.

Oh please, Microsoft Surface...how many years ago was that before your precious iPad? There is probably not a single thing that Apple designed that is not without precedent. It just looks that way to your infatuated eyes.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Surface

Microsoft Surface came out _after_ the iPhone. But what the hell does that have to do with anything?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com