If I had to bet, I'd bet that we were first, and that it happened due to an early filter. I can hear a crowd of doomers grabbing their pitchforks and torches, screaming "late filter, late filter," but I don't buy it. There are many plausible apocalypse scenarios that would wipe out most of humanity and make life miserable for a long time -- but finishing the job is a very different thing, and you have to reach deep into the scenario bag to find an apocalypse that actually does the trick. In contrast, there are a bunch of cellular biology innovations that sound magnificently tricky to evolve. Cellular membranes and the eukaryotic transition are two that stand out, but who knows. Point is: I find the "early filter" hypotheses easy to believe, and not just because they wind up being good news in the end.
> ["we really might be first"] plays into dangerous self-centered cognitive biases
I'm not so sure that this bias exists to a great extent, and in fact an opposite bias seems to be to prevalent - in almost all art, there is always an assumption of some older more advanced progenitor race, some old golden age of advanced wisdom. This is true happens in the Epic of Gilgamesh (the antediluvian civilization was more advanced) just as in modern video games.
My point was that it's also not unreasonable to not be surprised. After all, we know for sure that, even if the universe is eventually full of life, there must still exist at least one species with our experience - looking out and seeing no one else. That one species guaranteed to have this experience is of course the first one that starts colonizing.
To be clear again, I'm not claiming that we are for sure the first ones - there are many other reasonable explanations, but I believe this one is too.