This is a political story of the most Reddit-y kind. It's understandable how it ranked here; the title sounds fascinating. But the story isn't. I guess I probably agree with the story, but that doesn't mean it belongs on our site.
Flagged.
Actually, I'd argue the opposite. It has always been democratic, with the majority beating the outliers down when they disagree with groupthink, even if they're right.
It shouldn't be, but it is, and has been.
In a Thomas Kuhn kind of way, yes.
If you're going down that path, it's not a democracy, but a meritocracy. The opinion of a noted PhD in the field is markedly more weighty than the opinion of an unrelated bachelor.
It drives me absolutely crazy when I hear evolution deniers use the excuse that it's "just a theory," as though the phrase scientific theory means exactly the same thing as a theory in everyday layman's terms. I'd go so far as to say that this quirk of the language is as big an impediment to the widespread acceptance of evolutionary science as religiously based objections.
I like to formulate it a little different.
The theory of evolution is not a claim of truth.
It's simply the best model we have.
Dawkins proposed it would be better to use "theorem" rather than "theory", due to this confusing ambiguity.