Nothing Scales
jasonkerwin.com
jasonkerwin.com
“However, we rarely actually run the original intervention at larger scale. Instead, the tendency is to water it down, which can make things significantly less effective. Case in point: replicating an effective education intervention in Uganda in more schools yielded virtually-identical results, whereas a modified program that tried to simulate how policymakers would reduce costs was substantially worse. That’s the theory that Evidence Action favors for why No Lean Season didn’t work at scale—they think the implementation changed in important ways.“
"Note that this is a very different challenge from the “replication crisis” that has most famously plagued social psychology. The average treatment effect of appointments in our study matches the one in the other study I mentioned above, and the original study that motivated No Lean Season literally contains a second RCT that, in part, replicates the main result."
A HIV test may not be as important right now as getting that rotten tooth pulled, or getting clothes for a child so she can attend school, or getting food, or fixing the water pump or replacing the mosquito net.
Every person is in their own situation and doing anything other than empowering them is paternalistic.