Soap is fine on a cast-iron pan. Despite what people always say about non-stick, I don't find cast-iron and teflon to be really comparable. The reason I'd use cast-iron is because I want steady, even heating, want to develop a fond (which is difficult in teflon), etc. But no matter how good the seasoning I put on cast iron it's always going to suck for eggs unless I use a ton of oil.