I'm thinking about updating my projects but there too many options to choose from..
I'm thinking about updating my projects but there too many options to choose from..
Even ES2015 modules which some people still think is the big reason to keep Babel around: a) has full Browser support if you use type="module", but most people still want to pack their JS because just about no one is assuming HTTP/2 or HTTP/3 yet, and b) Babel has never done module format transforms, that's always been the domain of your packer (webpack, parcel, rollup, snowpack, what have you).
If you are updating your project stack in 2021 right now my personal top recommendation is that I really like the approach of snowpack (https://www.snowpack.dev/): ES2105 modules with <script type="module"> dev experience (which is great), great Typescript support, and a simpler overall config experience than most other options right now. (It uses esbuild under the hood rather than babel for dev and basic transforms/bundling. It can optionally piggy back webpack and parcel for Production bundling that needs more "power".) Especially that <script type='module"> dev experience feels great now (with Hot Module Reloading too) versus waiting for a full bundle even for dev builds.
I tried out Vite and it was a much smoother transition. As you said it seems to have more mindshare now and I would guess that is because the out of the box experience is better.
Looking at Vite's own comparison I don't see a strong reason to switch that would impact most of my projects: https://vitejs.dev/guide/comparisons.html#snowpack
But also I don't use Vue and I don't trust CSS Modules yet [1] which is their other most impactful feature of Vite.
([1] It still seems like reliable Browser support for CSS Modules is still 5 years away at the current rate, if it ever gets accepted as a standard. I don't think there's any obvious current objections and few browsers outside the Chromium hegemony to even really object today, but it's still one of those web standards that smells to me pessimistically like "it's never going to work right cross-browser", and even if I were less pessimistic about it, I prefer not to use them because I think they bloat CSS and subvert the intent behind cascading. At that point I think you might as well just use CSS-in-JS and that doesn't have to wait on web standards that may never arrive.)
https://blog.logrocket.com/why-you-dont-need-babel/
EDIT: Plus we also wanted to go on a package diet because we found ourselves doing too much cut-and-paste from github w/o really knowing how to use all the tools.