There’s been extensive research justification behind the vector-space model. BM25 is the 25th iteration of a model and well tuned BM25 holds the highest non nueral performance on many tasks including question answering[1]. Research has long found including factors other than total term matches matters. Such as IDF[2] and field length[3].
Have you benchmarked your relevance assumptions similarly? If so I’d love to see them and learn more!
1 - https://www.elastic.co/blog/improving-search-relevance-with-...
2- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/238123710_Understan...