Does the press have an ethical duty to out powerful gays in tech?
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
How about outing corruption, influence pedaling, and questionable campaign contributions?
EDIT: I finally read the article. The whole thing is a perversion of ethics. The idea that a journalist should out someone who is gay to celebrate gayness is wrong. If the person wants it known, let him do it himself. I suppose an exception is a gay bashing politician/activist who is in the closet, but that is just exposing hypocrisy. Same would be true of an anti-drug evangelist who is a secret drug dealer.
In fact, the idea that someone should be outed for the benefit of gays is the exact origin of the concept of "outing."
The end result may be that many people will start to believe that Tim Cook is gay.
How many people here even thought about Cook's personal life before reading the article?
Does anybody think his (or anybody elses) sexuality matters? If so, I'd like to hear why.
The press needs to start taking responsibility for what they are publishing. When a publication openly discusses things like 'and a recent tasteless photograph that I will not link ', or 'Whether or not you agree with what Gawker published in January', providing a link or not, the reader is likely inclined to search for said article or photo. It is as bad as writing the initial article yourself.
Though I don't see a way out of this, I think that in this situation, Ars took the wrong route, and I hope their editors pull the article.
- Unless they report Tim Cook's gay they're saying he's straight
- What can be written about his sexuality when he doesn't tell them, 'nothing' obviously isn't an option because of the previous point
- Therefore they ask is Cook is being unethical by not telling them about his sex life