This has been done with Indium Phosphide (InP). In fact, lasers, modulators and supporting circuitry have have been integrated together on InP in what is usually referred to as "Photonic Integrated Circuits". Infinera has been doing this for ~20 years. The drawback is you need a very specialized InP fab (which ultimately means high-cost and low volume).
If similar stuff could be done on ordinary silicon, that changes the game and opens up a huge range of possibilities.
After all, the first transistor wasn't remotely competitive with existing vacuum diodes in use at the time.
For the record I can't at all speak to the quality of this research paper, I'm only trying to address this comment specifically.
For an actual holy grail, ~every journal in the field needs the cred of your paper far more than you need them.
Otherwise we'll never get rid of those cartels.