We Do Not Need You To Design Anymore
journal.drawar.com
journal.drawar.com
I can guarantee you that neither Foursquare nor Zappos used a $500 stock or contest design, and I'd bet even money that MyTown, so deeply derided, spent more on design and art than either of those (not including salaried employees).
There's been undercutting forces in design for years. A decade ago a penny-pinching retailer picked a punk high school kid to do his website (disclosure: I was the kid) to save a few bucks and got a servicable if uneven product. Today he'd do 99designs and get the same. Real designers learn how to create, communicate and sell their value in tangible ways.
Certainly Google's no winning any awards for the visual design of their homepage, but they released it in a time when every other search engine had a 'Portal' on their homepage. On yahoo, lycos, excite, etc. search was one of like 200 modules on the page. It actually probably took some unique thinking and design for google to say "Let's make search the only the on the page."
You can certainly buy a theme for $500, but that theme isn't going to be designed for the optimal user experience for interacting with whatever it is that makes your site unique.
We (http://muckrock.com) launched our web app with a $30 stock theme and it was, in my opinion, the right decision at the right time. We still happily use it, and when we shopped around for designers, they were asking hundreds at the low end for work we found subpar.
On the other hand, a media site a friend runs recently invested heavily in design after years of frugality because advertisers demanded it, and the investment's paid off in dividends.
Ultimately, outside experts shouldn't dictate your company, whether they are designers, strategists, or even lawyers. You should, and in many cases forging ahead with a budget design, plain-english ToS or other off-the-path choice is the best one for your business.
I'm sure there are great designers, but a lot of designers seem to just be really good at churning out polished versions of whatever is hot now.
Picking the perfect font, colors, making the perfect graphics is an important and in my opinion completely different task, than making finding products easy by for example reducing the number of clicks required and such
Let use Vim as an example, the design of the interaction between the author and text is completely separate from the colorscheme
Interaction design, is not the same as Look and feel design is not the same as graphic design
I notice that most of the time, we speak of all design categories collectively, which really hurt the debate
A good interaction designer is not necessarily the same person as a graphic designer
I suspect that no one who says this sort of thing would actually hire a designer unless absolutely forced to. 99designs, et al simply replace the hapless employee whose incidental knowledge of graphic software would have otherwise put him in the uncomfortable position of building the website. It likely also saves some GD an annoying round of emails that go nowhere.
Both are thankful. Neither are hurt.
That's a great point. I think the article ignores a lot and may even be a textbook example of confirmation bias, and I don't think the author understands what good designers do, or more worryingly, why an off the shelf theme couldn't have worked for say, Facebook or Google Maps.
But that one point above is worth taking away, and something designers should think long and hard about.
My own personal opinion is that you can't polish a turd. But when you polish a diamond, it's makes quartz look like shit.
Full disclosure: I'm a designer.
But the choice is always yours.
Since you brought it up though; If you understand typography, you understand why it's important. You could take every other design embellishment out of any design and Typography would still be able to do most, if not all of the heavy lifting.
But I'll stress the point lest I be accused of forcing this opinion down your throat: No one is forcing you to adopt a designers viewpoint, and I'm not saying you're wrong if you don't.
Go ask Happy Cog what went into the redesign of Zappos and how much of it was just making the site "pretty" compared to the amount of time making it easy to find products and convert customers.
BTW linking to the websites of what are primarily mobile apps is pretty weak sauce.
Are you in this to make a quick buck, or to make a truly great product?