On the Party and the Princlings
scholars-stage.org
scholars-stage.org
China's "sell" is you should trade free expression for a bit of sanity and stability. I'm not a fan of that approach but again, the West currently isn't doing a good selling it's approach.
Humans are tribal and will form a network anywhere, but the freedoms and the way the government works is significantly different to me.
I grow weary of the “this is just like the west” mantra every time these things come up.
This article is not about a tiny minority's accumulation of wealth.
This article is about the massive accumulation of wealth by attaching oneself to a pre-destined Princeling. It's about there being old gerontocratic lines of power, long established, that sometimes rise and fall, but which are the and the only means towards wealth accumulation, the only means to power.
There's no parallel here. I fully am disgusted by the West, by how much we let wealth accumulate unchecked, by how much speech & political power wealth buys. It's vile & gross. But there's no vast stasis power, there's no systematic exploitation via governance that this article so eloquently writes up. The concerns you write seem petty to me, small, versus the vast indignity & inequity that the stasis, insular, carefully self-maintaining exploitative Chinese world that is described here puts upon it's regular citizens.
Where your are born in the West is HUGELY important. Granted, yes. But the system is not inherently oppressive, resistive to outsiders & upstarts. The West wants your initiative, your gumption, wants collaborative buy in, understands that gain is mutual. The west does reward initiative, gumption, starting things. The odds are not good- if one is not already born independently wealthy- but one can absolutely get ahead, make stuff happen, just by virtue of doing good, trying hard, one's own success & merits. That alone is super exceptionally contrasting. And there's few valent powers that be hovering around actively putting you in your place. Where-as in China one's fate seems utterly purely completely determined by one's friends, by who they saddle their wagon to. We're seeing such vulgar bold signs that the Jack Ma's & other tech-origin business-folk in China are simply not permitted, will be brought to heel.
Even a lot of successful musicians and actors are only able to attain success because of a safety net in the form a wealthy parents.
Class mobility is still unparalleled in the West.
Granted x2 you have the funding available to pay for it (much less the time and energy if you have to work to pay for it -- i.e. your parents did not finance your tuition, much less your living costs)
Granted x3 you actually have the mental ability to program at all (it is incredible how much this is taken for granted. No, you cannot just "teach" anyone anywhere off the street to understand programming).
Without the first, you're "relegated" (tongue-in-cheek) to: learning it in your off-time/going to a bootcamp and hustling hard to break into a first role at a most-certainly shitty-place-to-work at an under-market salary (think $60-70k for "mid-level"). If you do not have a low-performance job or a free place to stay, this is very difficult (bills, and the low-skilled work required to pay them, are exhausting).
If you can make it past that insanely high hurdle (see: your circumstances and luck are right), then yes: you too can join the upper middle class if your birth, and all the dominoes that fell after, are "up to the task."
N.B. it becomes vastly more difficult to learn anything at all when you're exhausted after a 10 hour day working (with or without a commute) a depressing job and wondering if you'll have any money left at the end of the month. Those weekends really do nothing at all except leave time to catch up on chores.
Unparalleled? Only on the surface, granted a robust social safety net. Without someone or something to take off the immense pressure of surviving alone, the most likely outcome is a downward-spiral into poor habits: substance abuse, poor diet, free-time spent in idleness to "recharge," poor sleep, etc. that all compound one another, and speed-up the fall into an inescapable pit of being permanently working class. Once in, to leave is an exception that is always hailed as proof of possibility (sweeping under the rug, how low the real probability is).
In this case, one could still semi-honestly say "class mobility" is still alive; but that would only apply to the offspring of our hypothetical working-class stiff (hopefully, who becomes a social safety net for these children -- but I'm not holding my breath).
as for software, many of my favorite coworkers are self taught former art history students who picked up some skills over time. they're great, they had wonderful skills. absolutely, this is person by person. but i think as much is just luckkng into a condusive good learning situation, getting to see the good perspectives & not get bogged down with the small stupid tech battles that dot the programming landacape. not getting burdened is a huge pro career skill wherever you are, but definitely super important for most tech folks.
the struggle is super real. but focusing only on the struggle, the difficulty; it disservices the potentials that do exist. there's a dual. everything is extremely hard & working towards better is precarious at best. the ways to fall off are vast. but let's not lretend that opportunity isnt here. not just in tech but in many ways to make futures in america, in many places. we can both acknowledge weakness & difficulty & struggle, and also accept potential. the two do not need to be so zero sum, only one can be true, in nature.
Yes, one can go through hell-and-back, roll the dice, and pray and hope that endless struggle for a better life will turn out well -- even if the odds are awful. No, this should not be the only way towards a better life or lauded as "unparalleled social mobility."
There it is. You're being prescriptive rather than descriptive. We're talking about the world as it is, you're talking about the world you want to be. Only one of these exists.
As bad as it is here, it's worse everywhere else.
Neither world exists. There is no objective observation. Our senses are limited, and our neurons filter through what we "observe," in order to create a cohesive story that doesn't disturb the one that's been continuously built all our lives. (Elsewhere, one could write an encyclopaedia's-worth of examples how our rational faculties are lacking in the absolute sense.)
The only thing that is different between the two is their proclivity for (or lack thereof) taking action.
> There is no objective observation.
This is a thing you can believe in. But if you do it will very much make it more difficult to relate. Striving to be objective is a very valid and worthwhile thing to work towards. Throwing your hands up and saying it's impossible is ultimately worse. I don't know you, but I'd be willing to guess that your "unbiased, descriptivist bent" was rather overly rational. HN gets hyper-rational and rewards that frame of mind, to the detriment of the community.
What I mean by working to be objective is to work to understand subjective, emotional states of mind. Emotionally, we want the world to be a certain way and when it's not, we become irrational, in ways that are actually rather predictable when you can reflect on them.
Objectivity is earned when you can understand not only the logical aspects of the world, but also the subjective ones too.
That China doesn’t allow this is a sign of deep insecurity. If you think both sides have a conspiracy of elites that manipulate everything for their own ends, at least in the US we can have TV hosts point it out without fear of torture. Is that not proof of moral superiority?
As you say yourself, it's a measure of relative security. US elites know their position can rarely be threatened by what is said in TV. We see the response to actual threats in the treatment of people who reveal the mechanisms of authority, most symbolically Edward Snowden.
The real comparison is for most people on most issues, in that regard, the US is immensely more free.
On the other end the 'Edward Snowdens' of China were executed long before anyone knew who they even were, for much lesser crimes.
There are 100's of thousands of people in Chinese prisons who are there merely for being of a certain ethnicity.
That is an odd example to trot out, given the overwhelmingly greater number of black people held in US prisons for basically the same reason.
But the topic you keep trying to distract us from is the relative security of the US elite class, which has nothing to do with underclass in prison.
Do US elites somehow prevent news of things that threaten them from being discussed?
I don’t think so, and I think many fall because of it.
Except it's plastered all over the TV, all over print and digital media, and literally everyone in the world knows about it, or has access to a lot of information about it!
In the meantime in China, a tennis player accused someone of something and was 'dissapeared', her accusations erased, and now she talks like a puppet prisoner of the state reading lines from the CCP PR team.
These comparisons are not helping your case.
The fact is that Gates's public persona is barely affected. He still gets to pump his investment targets and his favorite authors. It is hard to think of any examples besides Epstein demonstrating any kind of vulnerability among the elite. Even Trump is still running loose despite involvement in the first actual violent insurrection in 15 decades.
Epstein is the only US billionaire I have ever heard of so much as going to jail, never mind arraigned, tried, convicted, sentenced, or sent up. By contrast, top party apparats in China and oligarchs in Russia are disappeared every few years. Epstein is big news because it is a total fluke.
My assertion is that US elites are overwhelmingly more secure than Chinese elites, so devote correspondingly less attention to scrubbing the public discourse. Still, the ones getting transfusions of blood taken from infants are not being discussed on GMA.
You're off by quite a lot: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_United_States_Senate_bomb...
Prince Andrew's public indictment in more serious stuff repudiates the insinuation that the elite are not held to account. Maxwell is an Upper Class French Elite and her trial is visible now for the world to see.
Trump's goings on are also well publicized. They are not apparently illegal, so he's fine. As far as his supporters, well, that's too bad but his actions are public, and it's their absolute choice to support him. FYI being blunt about 'Building A Wall' is not inherently, objectively immoral. Trump is not technically corrupt: the IRS audits him extensively every single year, he had an investigations into his Russian dealings with over 300 witnesses and they turned up nothing on him.
Even Biden Jr's actions are constantly scrutinized.
Bernie Maddoff and other Pozni Schemers are in jail (soon Holmes) , andmost Billionaires don't commit crimes. They have too much to lose.
Could you imagine Xi being charged and imprisoned like Epstein? On trial like Maxwell? Massive Federal Investigation like Trump? Or private information about his apparently infidelity all over the internet? Xi's children in the press every few weeks where journalists pour over conflicts of interest?
In China they dissapear Billionaires for not following party orders, not for being corrupt. Just as in Russia, all rich prisoners are effectively political prisoners.
There is no practical difference, in China, between corruption and failing to follow party orders.
US elite are, as a rule, never so much as mentioned in the news, nor do they go to jail, never mind get disappeared. Thus, the US elite is overwhelmingly more secure than anyone in China, howsoever well placed. They have little to fear from TV chatter, but seem, by the evidence, entirely able to keep it tamped down to a minimum, except where they instead cultivate it.
Yes they do.
>never so much as mentioned in the news
Yes they are ... even in your own comments you mentioned some examples.
We’re talking about it now.
And, no one will ever say on TV that Gates was in bed with Epstein going back three decades. I have no way to learn the extent of the Koch's engagement. Gates maintains just as high a profile as before.
Trump is no longer president and not by his choice, the people chose that. That’s a great example right there.
There are thousands of American billionaires, most of whom you have never heard of. They do not go to jail. They do not worry about the prospect of going to jail. Exactly one (1) American billionaire did go to jail. He was executed before any trial could be staged, probably because of unpleasant facts he might have revealed about the other billionaires.
Trump is no longer president, but is very prominently not in jail, never mind disappeared. Prosecution of a president or ex-president for crimes committed while in office is different from that for regular citizens. He was not found innocent, in any sense. If impeachment had succeeded, he still would not go to jail. He is also not a billionaire, despite having threatened to sue people for having said so, but he does count as elite. Nothing said on TV could have even any slight effect on his comfort level. His position is absolutely secure.
Well, not every western country is an America. In Poland there is a law against insulting heads of states, public officers and flag. So not everywhere you can speak what you want.
The 'Billionaire Point System' of Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos may be a bit off, but remember that they are actually 'true innovators' changing the system at least slightly for the better at scale. If Amazon didn't exist, we may not have a collective replacement for it, and I wonder what 'The Cloud' would even look like if AWS didn't really get it going.
Frankly, the most 'odd' thing are billionaire Athletes and Crypto Traders.
The system is not entirely equal, but I wouldn't say it's rigged either.
"China's "sell" is you should trade free expression for a bit of sanity and stability. "
? No, Hong Kong under the English - was a 'trade' of freedoms for prosperity.
Mainlanders don't get any stability, wealth, rule of law, or freedom. What you might get is an apartment and maybe a car, where your parents could not, but I think the argument could be made that they would have that were they to liberalize.
If China in the last 20 years, went the direction of Korea and Japan did in the 1970s and 1980s, which is to say loosen up and liberalize after 'post war rebuild', then they might be that much wealthier.
It's getting harder and harder to commit that the CCP is essential or necessary for growth. I guess we'll start to find out in the next 20 years.
All CCP sells is perception. They are masters at that since they control everything. The west sure has problems, but it is better to live free, coz once you trade freedom, sanity and stability sure won't be in your hands anymore.
Such perspectives, in the OP and elsewhere, implicitly assume an inevitable history leading to this moment.
It assumes the current 'common wisdom' is somehow Truth, maybe arrived at through the errors of the past, and not an equally myopic misconception that will, in 20 years, be the errors of someone else's past.
It also denies agency, as if the current situation was and the future is inevitable.
I wonder: Is it similar to (IIRC) communism's heavy theoretical reliance on an inevitable force of history?
This. Love it or leave it.
Its brilliant social engineering to get the most dangerous elements the appearance of choice... towards their own exile.
The CCP is not the first communist ruling class to implement it, but they certainly seem to have perfected it.
This level of opacity from an organisation that controls 1 billion people are claims to have either the largest or second largest national economy globally is quite startling.
Is this the state of knowledge? Compare that to the scrutiny every single important US politicians gets. Kavenaugh was literally bringing out his childhood diary and grilled about his conduct from 1982; large parts of the debate on that are part of the public record for anyone to look up. There are radical differences of approach here.