Specifically, if you can find someone to help you with this, have them show you a Statistical Market Conditions report for a full year from the day you’re gathering this info (known in industry as a 1004MC. They can easily create this in most MLS software like FlexMLS). The trick is defining the amount of house (sq footage), the lot size (your prerogative on space), and any other features you deem important to your new home, along with being specific to the area you want to live in (a MC report over a whole city will not give the granular detail you might be looking for).
Since it is a part of most appraisal assignments , I use this constantly to make sure that my head is in the game when it comes to what has actually sold in the market for the type of house I’m appraising, as well as seeing what people choose to list for. The top of the page usually has a table with headings that look like:
[12-7 months ago][6-4 months ago][3 months ago - current]
The items in the table go over amount of listed and sold properties, as well as the days on market, along with median statistics. Super useful to get a feel of what has actually happened, not what people want to happen.
The issue for those who do not work in the real estate field is that you do not have access to all the data we have, and it is a shame because people should be able to make well informed decisions on their own rather than getting advice from someone who stands to gain monetarily from the transaction you are making.
The other thing that rubs me the wrong way when I hear people looking to Zillow, Opendoor, or any of the other iBuying firms for what their house is “actually worth” they do not realize that all these companies are doing is scrapping or has their own access to local MLS systems and layering their own pricing models over the data that is already there. I used to work as part of an internal team at one of these places before I kept into the family business, and I know that we were not the only company doing so to get people to use our platform.
Ultimately, my advice is if you can get your hands on access to one of these systems, because MOST data on these multiple listing services is regulated to make sure realtors don’t lie about their listings, and is usually tied into your state’s assessors info (especially if you are in an open data state).