Hacker News Reader

Comment by drcongo | Hacker News Reader

Sorry, yes. There's multiple sources, but a lot of it collected here: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Desktop/issues/4461

They keep shutting down tickets about it, refuse to review a PR that implemented it for them, and won't even tick the box on the Signal iPad app that would make it available on M1 Macs (where side-loaders have already confirmed for them that it works perfectly.

90% of my Signal usage was on desktop, so this has left such a bad taste that I'd rather use almost anything else now.

View on HN

> won't even tick the box on the Signal iPad app that would make it available on M1 Macs

Isn’t that box ticked by default? I think what Signal has done is gone in and deliberately unticked it to make you use the Intel Mac app in Rosetta rather than the iPad app.

Edit: yup

> After you sign the updated developer agreement, the App Store automatically makes compatible iOS apps available to users of a Mac with Apple silicon. However, if you’re already planning to ship a macOS version of your app, or if your app doesn’t make sense on the Mac, you can change your app’s availability in App Store Connect.

Wow. That's even more user-hostile then.

I can see it making sense if you're a cross platform shop and a high quality Mac app is something that you're prioritizing. You might not want people to inadvertently happen on an iPad app that will run on the Mac but is worse than the Mac app.

But it doesn't sound like Mac is a big priority here, so who knows why they would do that.

> tick the box on the Signal iPad app that would make it available on M1 Macs

This annoys me the most. I don't see the downside of them enabling it. It would bring the Mac client into feature parity with the IOS client and eventually reduce complexity. It seems like it would be an easy win-win.

The reason for this is that the iOS and macOS security models for attachments are not the same, and so additional work has to be done before it could work. It’s not just click and go.

(At least this is what I read months ago)

Is there a substantial benefit to running something like Signal on M1 natively vs. through Rosetta? I don't have an M1 Mac so I don't a feel for this issue but my understanding was that between Intel and M1+Rosetta, x86-64 native applications run approximately the same.

Battery life, especially with regards to Electron.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com