If it turns out that "natural talents and gifts" are really just due to a better critical period for the child, then the liberals here are really shooting themselves in the foot with this argument.
If it turns out that "natural talents and gifts" are really just due to a better critical period for the child, then the liberals here are really shooting themselves in the foot with this argument.
That said, twin studies do provide substantial evidence that giftedness is highly heritable and probably significantly genetic.
I am well aware of how twin studies but any claim about the genetic component kinda falls apart for me based on them as the children were in the same pregnant mother at the same time.
> any claim about the genetic component kinda falls apart for me based on them as the children were in the same pregnant mother at the same time.
They do somewhat control for pregnancy by comparing identical vs fraternal twins, and finding a higher correlation in intelligence between the former, as well as a far more similar brain structure in regions known to be related to intelligence (frontal cortex).
Anyway, it's impossible to get rid of all confounds via twin studies. But this doesn't mean that twin studies provide zero evidence. It just means the evidence can't be fully conclusive. It just strongly points in the direction of genetics.
Predicting IQ from genetic information alone should remove all the of compounding factors (except those introduced by IQ measurement itself) but can only serve as a lower bound unless predictor overfitted the study data.
> The truth is most likely somewhere between those two.
> but can only serve as a lower bound unless predictor overfitted the study data.
Yes, but the truth is likely somewhere much closer to the upper bound (twin studies) than the lower bound (genome studies).Genome studies are only good for lower bounds. They're a new methodology that isn't good with complex traits. For example, they can only explain 20-30% of the variability in hair color even though we know that hair color is almost 100% genetic due to the observation that identical twins always have the same hair color. Intelligence is much more complex than hair color, so it's no surprise that this method has failed to explain more than 5%. Further, these studies often rely on weak proxies like educational attainment because of the difficulty of IQ testing at scale, and the studies that do try to IQ test at scale suffer from small sample sizes which impacts the ability to find results due to being underpowered.
Also, IQ becomes more correlated with parents as you age, suggesting childhood environment plays a less important role.
In addition, the jump in correlation from fraternal to identical suggests more role for genetics than merely a few %.
But I remember they found a surprising amount of similarities in twins brought up in different environments.
Of all the things to evaluate the policy on, this is a real poor proxy as whether there are gifted people or not usually has little bearing on the overall health of math education across a very highly populated state.
I never disagreed with whether they exist or not. I just don't see why this is such a sore point for people. I can virtually guarantee that the existing education system in CA didn't really benefit the gifted folks either. If I were setting up the program for a whole state, whether it will be good for a Jacobi/Euler/Gauss is totally irrelevant. We're not going to make people who show up once every 50-100 years be a major factor in educating millions of people.
Your reply is that we shouldn't design a state-wide math program for extreme outliers. But no one said we should! We only said that we should design a math program that acknowledges a diversity in innate math ability (as proven by the existence of extreme outliers, and the many, many less extreme outliers).
To me, it seems these changes are oriented towards helping everyone succeed in STEM, even those who don’t think they’re math people. Which, again, is less to do with their actual abilities and much more to do with their mental dialogue.
This makes a ton of sense. Basically any skill or habit you might want to develop can be easily thwarted if you’re struggling mentally with discipline, focus, self-image, etc. In my opinion, the “mental game” is crucial to nearly everything and doesn’t get enough focus. (Think of how in sports, a bad mental game can easily loose you the physical game even if you’re an incredible athlete.)
I doubt these educational changes would ever have much of an impact on bonafide geniuses, because they are operating in an entirely different context.
It should be both.