I’ll admit that I lack sufficient math and physics education to fully appreciate the study, but after reading the actual abstract I must say that it certainly seems more grounded than either of those two extreme reactions.
There’s a lot of suggestive and uncertain language being used like “to be qualitatively quite similar”, “correlates well with”, or “correlation would suggest”, and I’m uncertain if I should Interpret the rhetoric as conservative excitement sprinkled with self doubt, or if this is the physics PhD researcher version of ostentatious nerd flexing with a bit of CYA in case future research/results don’t pan out.
I’m looking forward to reading the comments of the European physics and engineering PhDs in the morning.