> since that number is not based on actual sales of the land in question, it's just hand-waving
Actual land is sold in a lot of markets. That sets a great benchmark for "comparable transaction" types of valuation analyses which tend to be the most reliable.
If one acre of land is sold, there is a great baseline for the whole surrounding area.
I passed all 3 CFA exams and agree it's not an exact science, but as far a valuation analyses go, this one is pretty easy. Valuing something like intellectual property, goodwill impairment analyses, 409a valuations are much harder.