Hacker News Reader

Comment by siquick | Hacker News Reader

I have never experienced any issues with a virtualenv and pip.

python3 -m venv venv && source venv/bin/activate && pip install -r requirements.txt

Python standard library is great and its a nice languate if you like the syntax but aside from a few constants like Django, Flask, and Pandas, the ecosystem feels like it is slowly turning into a fragmented mess.

View on HN

If you're building a package, pip install -e . is preferable to -r requirements.txt. Most projects don't need and shouldn't use requirements.txt. The only ones that do are where you're shipping a whole tested environment out, like a docker image for deployment. And in that case you need to be using something like pip-tools to keep that requirements for up to date.

Same, I use two small bash scripts in my projects bin/ directory, "venv-create" for the creation of the .venv/ and "venv-python" for running the effective version of Python from the .venv/ -- this sets environment variables such as PYTHONPATH and PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE and provides a single approach for running project files and packages.

I get versioned requirements files for the project base requirements, and also for each (version, implementation) of python, in case they are changes, and this has proven to be reliable for me.

It's all about finding the minimal-but-complete convenience / ergonomic solution over the, err, inconvenience of packaging. I also marvel at when I attempt to explain these things to experienced programmers, I only manage to convince them 50% of the time at most.

That's what I use as well. It works great, it's built in and it's easy to use and understand. Only issue is when you upgrade the version of Python you're running. In that case you might need to rebuild your virtualenv, but that's super easy.

I use the same solution to have multiple versions of Ansible installed.

If you need to run multiple version of Python, then virtualenvs might not be enough, but that's honestly not a problem I have. New version of Python, great, let's me just rebuild my virtualenv and get back to work.

One of the most important rules I have regarding working in Python is: Never, never ever, install ANYTHING with the global pip. Everything goes in to virtualenvs.

> python3 -m venv venv && source venv/bin/activate && pip install -r requirements.txt

... bless my `zsh` shell history for these incantations. I don't think I have any hope of remembering it -- probably because of all the old virtualenv incantations!

Kind of agree with pipenv though. It's painfully slow, but it abstracts away having to worry about various requirements files (eg: dev vs prod) and the .lock keeps things consistent.

I use this same setup but with a requirements folder. Inside I have a base.txt, dev.txt and tests.txt where dev.txt starts with '-r tests.txt', etc.

It's very handy for having different environments but doesn't lend itself to a lockfile.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com