This seems like bad faith to me based on my experience when I worked for AWS. As they repeated many times at Re:Invent last week, they've been doing this for 15+ years. I distinctly remember seeing banners like "Don't update the dashboard without approval from <importantSVP>" on various service team runbooks. They tried not to say it out loud, but there was very much a top-down mandate for service teams to make the dashboard "look green" by:
1. Actually improving availability (this one is fair).
2. Using the "Green-I" icon rather than the blue, orange, or red icons whenever possible.
3. They built out the "Personal Health Dashboard" so they can post about many issues in there, without having to acknowledge it publicly.