I'm not smart enough to know if something like Webb can be horizontally scaled into 100 or 1000x small sats to produce the same result.
My guess is not.
I think we need a super sharp knife and it's worth the investment.
I'm not smart enough to know if something like Webb can be horizontally scaled into 100 or 1000x small sats to produce the same result.
My guess is not.
I think we need a super sharp knife and it's worth the investment.
But you can use many separate mirrors with artifacts to replicate a perfect mirror, as long as you are able to do some post-processing on the array of mirrors with artifacts. And with proper post-processing you may even be capable of extracting additional information which a single perfect mirror would not be able to deliver.
> But you can use many separate mirrors with artifacts to replicate a perfect mirror
It is theoretically possible, but is it practically so? My argument/usage of the analogy is that it isn't today. That as the analogy says, if we put up 100x small mirrors we just get 100 dull knives and blurry science[0].
[0] https://images.ctfassets.net/cnu0m8re1exe/3grbH0eWtw0AxG3MUT...
Some examples: https://www.dragonflytelescope.org/gallery.html is an array of telescopes (long off the shelf photographic lenses) to achieve exactly that. Photographic lenses tend to give higher image quality, but don’t gather enough light. Solution? Stack many of them and point in the same direction. It’s not just a flight of fancy, they made some breakthrough science with this.
A somewhat less relevant case is ALMA - millimetre wave array in the Atacama. Millimetre waves are a bit longer than IR, somewhat between IR and microwave, and telescopes look like radio dishes, not optical devices. Anyway, the array stacks many tens of such receivers to produce one antenna with a massive effective diameter. In this case, the key advantage is in fact resolution: by spreading the dishes around, you get much higher overall resolution than one massive dish, something we probably couldn’t achieve with IR (too computationally expensive).
Whether launching 10 satellites with 1/3 mirror diameter is cheaper is a whole different question.
If that's the case Webb has been done many times and is super easy.
Not to mention, each of these 100 units would require the same shielding from radiation as the giant one does for the same reasons. We chose L2 for a very good reason; where are these 100 going to go? What are the odds that each one will end up where it needs to be x100 attempts?
We've basically maxed out what Hubble can do. While a sharper visible light telescope would be nice, we need longer wavelengths to see "further back" in history. i.e. Webb
Another thing Hubble did was kick off Dark Energy, but then we needed different instruments to know more about the things that Hubble started. GAIA, Plank satellites are doing nutso things in that space.
All to say, Hubble is f'ing great, let's bring it home and put it in a museum to help inspire the next generation.
My understanding is that all major observatories, and certainly Hubble, are overbooked by a factor of 3 or more for months, and sometimes years, in advance.
Which implies that having 3 Hubbles would allow us to do more research than we can do today. It's not ready for the museum while astronomers still battle over who gets to use it.
An instrument doesn't have to be cutting edge in order to be useful and produce valuable results. Even today, amateur astronomers are still making discoveries (asteroids, sometimes comets) with telescopes that major observatories would have laughed at 100 years ago already.
"The telescope that ate astronomy" (Webb) will undoubtedly make important discoveries. Whether it will be worth its cost considering what we could have built for the same price (such as 10 ELTs!) remains to be seen.
I do have to believe that any satellite designed specifically for one type of measurement would be more robust and cost less than something that did more than one, but I suppose that's not really true. Sometimes multiple measurements simply complement each other too much not to use.
Usually with telescopes you need a huge aperture to see dim things, unless you're willing to wait a long time for an image to resolve. Not everything is super dim, though, so maybe having telescopes with an aperture much smaller than 6.5 meters would make sense for those tasks.
I don't know if there's some other reason James Webb needs a huge aperture than being able to resolve and image quickly. (Maybe the lower wavelengths don't behave on small mirrors?) If that's it, though, it seems like having backup would be good.
Fun fact for dimness: We are pretty much at “we can count every photon that comes” so if you want to pick up far away things, increasing the aperature is also one of the few things you can do. But at that point you’d probably prefer multiple telescopes if you can align them properly
From a physics point of view there really isn’t much difference between light and radio waves. Both is just em radiation. But the absorption by matter (well really gas, there is nothing else) changes with wavelength too. And you’d optimize the ccds for whatever you want to look at. So that would be the primary consideration and keep in mind these things tend to also be build as tech demos (which also means you typically don’t get to realize all design capabilities in action). So “because it’s the most we could get away with” is a reasonable reason