Hacker News Reader

> The DMT experience is so far beyond any rational thinking or explanation that it boggles my mind how anyone would try to analyze it.

Some people have attached metaphorical debuggers to their brains, which give them additional capabilities.

More generally, some people may have access to analytical tools that you and I may not even be aware of.

View on HN

It's not a problem of the "amount" of analysis capabilities. The experience is orthogonal to rational. It's the same Chinese Room - no matter how many analytical brains you would throw on understanding what "red" qualia means, you won't be able to explain it and won't be able to experience it until you did.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room

We can analyze many “irrational” brain states from the outside. I’d suggest looking at modern fMRI results.

I’d also suggest forgetting about the Chinese Room. It might have been an interesting thing to discuss 40 years ago. It’s just sad to see people taking it seriously today.

Why would the Chinese Room be irrelevant? It's directly connected to the hard problem of consciousness, which is more relevant than ever, if anything.

fMRI can analyze a brain, not an experience, proving that one equals another brings us back to the same problem.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com