My biggest gripe with pretty much everything (Roam, Dendron, etc) is that nothing is plaintext. I love the lack of lockin when everything is based upon plaintext. Furthermore you can use whatever editor you like.
My biggest gripe with pretty much everything (Roam, Dendron, etc) is that nothing is plaintext. I love the lack of lockin when everything is based upon plaintext. Furthermore you can use whatever editor you like.
I'm pretty happy with it so far.
I still use Sublime to edit the files quickly and when I don't need features provided by Obsidian plugins.
A minor gripe is that the iCloud sync is really really bad. Perhaps that's more on Apple than Obsidian, but frequently editing of the same files across multiple devices is a pain point today. To their credit, they have acknowledged this and now offer their own first-party sync service, but I think $96/year to sync a folder of Markdown files from my laptop to my phone is excessive.
On one hand it is nice for basic tools like grep, custom editors, easy backup, etc. However "lockin" is something i keep pausing on.. because for any advanced features you include, say spaced repetition over items in the document, becomes a unique DSL for your application most likely. Yea, it could be made from "just markdown" or w/e, but the functionality still only works in that one app.
Eg i used some other Space Rep tool which advertised using just markdown, cool! But i can't port it anywhere, so yay it's plain text but the functionality still need to be refactored to work with other tools.
This problem becomes more apparent when you add more complex features. Each unique/novel feature creates unique DSL to store state in "plaintext", which to me starts feeling like it destroys the core premise of plaintext.
Thoughts on this issue?
https://github.com/foambubble/foam
Though admittedly I rarely use backlinking.