From this example alone it's clear that the threat of punishment works. If you want a better way to deter crime, you have my full support. But if you cease an effective measure and delay months before implementing another one, your transition process is none.
Imagine if a bank would freeze all your funds just because they're transitioning to a new "better" system. Even for a single week.
Some people simply will not get invested in a cooperative endeavor, no matter what. There is no way to "make sure they have skin in the game." Those people need to be incapacitated from causing further harm to society until such time as they pose no such threat.
Who are "those people", though? There is a wildly disproportionate amount of attention focused on a very small sliver of theft.
Consider that amount of stolen wages by employers recovered dwarfs retail theft by a factor of 3 to 1 [1]. The total amount taken is likely significantly higher. Walgreens — the very company for which people cite store closures as a consequence of shoplifting — just paid out a $4.5m settlement for stealing from thousands of employees in California from 2000 to 2017 [2].
Consider that over the past 20 years, police have stolen $68 billion from people without due process [3]. Since 2014, they've stolen more money than burglars [4]. As a society, we've actually chosen to make this legal via civil asset forfeiture.
And yet no one is calling for crackdowns on employers who steal from their employees. No one is calling for police to be "incapacitated from causing further harm to society". Indeed, the goal of the activists pushing to recall Chesa Boudin want to give the police more power — even though they steal more than shoplifters!
[1] https://www.epi.org/publication/wage-theft-bigger-problem-fo...
[2] https://popular.info/p/a-tale-of-two-thefts
[3] https://boingboing.net/2020/12/21/us-police-have-stolen-68-b...
[4] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/11/23/cops-...
(I don't necessarily agree about civil forfeiture, in that the police are acting on behalf of the state - the structure itself is what is taking property without due process. That's more harmful to individuals because there's no recourse, but the fault is primarily with the law rather than with individual officers.)
Re: civil asset forfeiture, I don't understand the distinction you're making. Why do you support accountability for individual actors within corporate structures (managers underpaying employees) but not within carceral structures (police confiscating from civilians)? In both cases, the theft is enacted by individual agents and protected by the overarching structures.
That said, I don't even agree that it's solely a structural problem! The median amounts taken can be as low as a few hundred dollars [1]. I can't find the link, but the last time civil forfeiture came up on HN there was a story saying that police routinely shake down pedestrians for small amounts, knowing that the cost to get their money back would exceed the amount taken.
[1] https://www.propublica.org/article/police-say-seizing-proper...
No. Civil forfeiture is unfortunately the law of the land. Individual police officers are not responsible for domestic law or department policy.
Employee wage theft is emphatically not the law of the land. Managers and employers who do this are committing a crime. They are responsible for their own actions because those actions are not sanctioned by law or required by policy.
Additionally, in the case of wage theft, the bad actor often benefits directly if they are the owner of the establishment or, as a manager, they receive a bonus related to cost savings. By contrast, civil forfeiture benefits the government, not the individual officer.
> A few years ago, when I was at the public defender's office, my very poor clients kept telling me the same story: they would be walking down the street and DC police would stop them, search them at gunpoint, tell them to open their wallets, and take all the cash they had. (2)
> The wildest part? The DC police would then send them a letter saying that, if they wanted to challenge the police taking of their cash, they would need to pay either $250 or 10% of the amount taken, whichever was more! (3)
> …
> A lot of the time, cops were taking $5 and $30 from extremely poor people who were struggling to meet the basic necessities of life for their children, like buying food and diapers and shoes. (7)
That is called mugging. And it may be the law of the land, but that doesn’t absolve these dirty cops of their misdeeds. Just like those managers, individual officers are making the choice to steal from people, incentivized and protected by their department.
[1] https://twitter.com/equalityalec/status/1412428330792542209?...
What makes you say that? Is fear of punishment not a reasonable deterrent from crime?