Why, next thing you know these activist teachers will be telling our kids that racism is bad. The horror.
Why, next thing you know these activist teachers will be telling our kids that racism is bad. The horror.
This sure sounds like a lot more than "telling our kids that racism is bad".
We would all benefit from a direct link to a recording or summary from this CTA conference. I suspect the reality is more banal than claimed: teachers are frequently the only (trustworthy) adult contacts outside of a child's family, and can be a resource for children who might otherwise be pushed into conversion therapy or other objectively harmful and outright illegal[1] "treatments" by their guardians.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conversion_therapy#Legal_statu...
There's a difference between simply not informing them and actively hiding the information from them. Aibgail implies they are doing the latter. She may be lying or misrepresenting things, but the latter is bad.
What's being done here is heavy surveillance by the school, and the exclusion of that surveillance information from the parents. If the argument is that kids have no right to privacy, fine - share it with the parents.
But regardless of the merit of the particular ideas under discussion now, they are a lot richer and more complex than simply telling kids "racism is bad".
I remember how it was teachers "failing" to "teach the controversy" re: evolution when I was in middle school; now they're "subverting" the democratic will! Gack.
"Subversion of the consent of the governed" can be anywhere from "making the kids smoke cigarettes at recess" to "teaching the works of MLK Jr. even though it makes local parents uncomfortable".
The classic example of this is the whole "states' rights" canard re: the American Civil War. The states' rights to what, exactly?
People often defend the hard-to-defend by talking in generalities and appealing to abstractions. The real test of the idea is if you can defend it both generally and specifically.
The states have rights according to the tenth amendment (the last amendment in the 'Bill of Rights'):
>"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
Why don't you answer the question? The Civil War was fought over a state's right to do what, exactly?
[1] https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-sources/declarati...
[2] That word happens to be mentioned only 11 times in the entirety of the text of Huckleberry Finn, by the way.
[3] The word 'property' appears 16 times, and refers to human beings in every single one of those instances.
> Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery-- the greatest material interest of the world. Its labor supplies the product which constitutes by far the largest and most important portions of commerce of the earth.
The quote you provided could mean literally anything, from regulating the sale of beef to taxing bread. I suspect neither hamburgers nor dinner rolls were the subject of the Civil War.
Which rights were in dispute?
>> https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/01/underground-...
And, whether you like it or not, must of the public does want its teachers to be supportive of children who aren't straight or cis.
I would use the same term ('subvert') for a government contractor siphoning government funds for activities outside their contract terms. I really don't know what else to call this.
I thought unions existed to collectively bargain for compensation and working conditions. When working conditions are related to policy, they can negotiate with the employer for 'concessions' (or agreements as the case may be). One (potential) problem occurs when the politicians and the unions agree on something, and enter into contracts with the purpose of 'locking-in' policy decisions beyond the politicians' terms.
It also works. Have you heard of democratic schools (also known as free schools)? The kids govern themselves, set rules, dictate curriculum. They have quite strong outcomes for students.
What a privileged childhood you must've had to think that this is a viable schooling system for anyone but upper-middle-class hippie rich kids. You do realize middle schoolers are routinely recruited into gangs in rough cities like Chicago, right?
So, are you saying that there's some inherent difference between rich kids and inner city kids? Like, beyond their circumstances? Because if rich hippie kids can govern themselves, and inner city kids can't, that is either because rich kids are just better - or that poor kids have shitty circumstances that take that ability away from them. If you believe the former, we can't go any further because you're just racist or classist or both. If you believe the latter, then clearly kids deserve a say in their circumstances wherever they have that ability - and where they don't, something else needs to change first.
It looks like empty pseudo-accusations of racism finally made it to HN, all nicely disguised as a false dilemma (either you're a racist or you agree with me; very classy). This is where I bid you adieu.
But since we're on the subject of taking the high road, I will say that you did, moments earlier, accuse me of being privileged to the point of being out of touch. If you want good and civil discourse, maybe ease up on the personal attacks yourself? Thanks
Should the people sill have their free will to chose? Yes, absolutely but as early as possible? Probably not. Young people make stupid decisions that's why they are not allowed to do certain things and decide certain things. If a kid isn't allowed to get a tattoo why is it controversial that it isn't allowed to take hormones that permanently alter their body and make them infertile.
Also lets just assume that from all teenager going trough puberty that would be eligible for hormone therapy on the basis of their own decision, a fraction would eventually have a "normal life" if no hormone treatment is done. Lets say its 10%.
So by giving 100% of eligible teenagers hormone treatment this wound mean 10% are permanently harmed versus giving no teenager hormone treatment where 90% would eventually get it anyway when they are older. Which doesn't seem to have a measurable negative effect on their overall mental health and well-being. Then this would mean no early treatment for anyone safes 10% or the other way around early treatment causes 10% collateral damage.
Obviously there has to be a middle ground somewhere but I would say there is good evidence that pushing/motivating people/kids/teenagers is overall likely doing more harm than good. And pushing/motivating based on some personal ideology is not in the interest of the people/kids/teens anyway. They may truly believe what they do helps and have no intention to harm anyone but so do the Scientology people. It just not what a school should do.
You're also confused into thinking that the school is encouraging one option when the article doesn't even suggest that is happening. Instead, it says teachers encourage students who show interest into joining Gay Straight Alliances to help prevent violence against LGBT people regardless of their personal medical choices.
I wish the anti-trans crowd would be more honest. Just come out and say that you hate trans people, that you wish to roll-back the hard-won rights they have at the moment; that you disagree with the international scientific and medical community about best treatment; that you're happy to lie about the evidence to try to sound more reasonable and less hate-driven.
And declaring everyone who disagrees with you as anti-trans who want to take people rights away and what not, make you the intolerant, hate-drive person you seem to see in others.
No I don't. But there is a consensus that certain people can not make such a decision i.e. kids and I think that is correct. I dont want to decide for them at all. I just pointed out who should not make the decision, a non-mature person who has a very limited view on the magnitude of the decision, has zero medical expertise on the topic and is possible in a very complicated mental and emotional state.
I also pointed out that statistically speaking some strategies cause "collateral damage" and other don't. While each case has to be looked at individually one should not ignore the fact that contrarily to people wishes, no swift medical treatments are probably favorable.
>You're also confused into thinking that the school is encouraging one option when the article doesn't even suggest that is happening.
No. I'm not confused and that's not what I'm thinking or said.
Beside that, separating people by letting them joining different alliances is an absurd way to prevent violence.
Separating people is not what a Gay-Straight Alliance does. It's in the name.
Yes and and that should not change.
>Separating people is not what a Gay-Straight Alliance does. It's in the name.
Not sure if naiv or trolling but obviously the name is completely irrelevant. If certain people are included and other excluded its not an alliance between these people.
>The right approach would be to talk to real life young people and young adults in this position and come to an understanding based on their experiences.
Why would you assume I have not? And understanding their experience is fine but their experiences don't change numbers, studies, statistics etc. You can argue the numbers are weak and that is true (we need better data to make informed decisions) but that still does not give "their experience" any kind of value as a counterargument.
If there is evidence that shows that lives can be saved by not doing certain medical treatments, especially early treatments and instead postponing them with minimal negative side effects, how would the "understanding the experience" of individuals affect this? They might disagree but that doesn't make it not true and in their best interest.
We generally dont ask people with comparable problems what they think is best for them and then just do that. We may ask them to study the problem and even as part of the decision making process how to treat them. All of this is fine if done on an individual level. But if we make an overall statement it certainly should not be to "understanding their experience" by listening to the affected people and then do as they wish. There is literally no medical condition out there that is treated this way.
>Middle ground positions sound ok, but this this a squishy topic with infinite dimensions and designing systems that try to take a balanced approach do harm in unobvious and subtle ways.
Well we are expressing opinions here and sometimes you cant get them across in a "middle ground" way. But looking at each case individually seems kinda middle ground to me.
Yes, the quantity and quality are the most important part of this whole discussion. Anyone should have a handle on these before drawing conclusions that intend to reduce harm. I'll make an analogy. How many times have you had to remind someone to profile before making optimizations? Studying harm is the profiling and making changes to reduce it is optimizing.
> Why would you assume I have not?
That's fantastic! What did they say about this?
> There is literally no medical condition out there that is treated this way.
There's literally no medical condition that intersects society this way. Why apply a blanket approach to all medical conditions?
> looking at each case individually seems kinda middle ground to me.
It sounds nice, but the outcome is that individual practitioners will exert their individual biases[1]. This is why we have things like DSM[2] in psychology, and in this specific case WPATH[3].
1. Don't mistake this that my goal is zero biases. We're talking about reducing harm, not eliminating it. Let's not let perfect be the enemy of good.
2. An example of standards
You dont do something because it "only" 5% worse and stop if its 10% worse. You dont need to know how much worse it is. If its worse its worse. If it cause preventable collateral damage then its not okay to do it anyway.
Literally every medical condition will take into account quality of life before, during, and after treatment.