You can't make a new gold out of thin air but you can a new crypto out if thin air. This is why all crypto is fictional, if you missed the last speculation bubble, just make a new crypto.
And for BTC wether a new crypto is made or not doesn't really matter that much. (Through it can, if it implicitly shakes the believe in BTC, which is quite unlikely.)
(Also some crypto currencies are build with different marked mechanism in mind, where minting new tokens is not just possible but expected/required.)