Russian-Made Elbrus CPUs Fail Trials, 'A Completely Unacceptable Platform'
tomshardware.com
tomshardware.com
> SPEC CPU 2017 2.62 (base) ~ 3.15 (peak) times slower
> PGbench/PostreSQL 1.7 (read only profile) ~ 3.3 (read write profile) times lower
So, Elbrus is just 2-3 times slower in these tasks than powerful Intel's CPUs that took millions of dollars to design. As Elbrus has lower clock frequency and larger process node, so this is expected. It is difficult to outperform a CPU that has smaller transistors and more of them; you need either to have more transistors or they have to be smaller; or both.
But Elbrus loses a lot in Java tests:
> Java 23 ~ 26 times higher response time
I guess this could be because Java JIT doesn't support Elbrus architecture.
I think that is wrong assumption because CPUs nowadays don't become "orders of magnitude faster" in several years.
If the architecture was actually failing - that is, if it were dumping core when running regular workloads, or crashing, or corrupting data - that would be a real reason to not use it.
But it seems like it's simply slower than they'd like, plus there are features they want (better casing, better LEDs, remote management). These don't have much to do with actually running code.
Speed isn't everything. We don't put supercomputers in to space - we put slow but extremely reliable processors in to space. Slow and reliable is much, much more important to space and financial (non-trading) applications than fast and not-as-reliable.
Optimizing JIT occurs on a software release schedule, not a hardware release schedule.
See how fast the hardware catches up with AMD and Intel. Considering how much better it is than in 2019, pace of progress is pretty good. And we’ll have fresh hardware security bugs to find and exploit, more fun for all.
The USSR knockoff of the Concorde was also superior on paper in certain aspects, but firsthand accounts of flying on it and its operational history clearly expose its inferiority to western technology.
Would it deliver on what Shuttle promised? No. Would it be more flexible? Yes. Would it be a good match for the other Soviet space gear? No. Had the Soviet Union not collapsed, would it have evolved into a more usable vehicle? That we'll never know.